Johnson Mitchell A, Barchick Stephen R, Kerbel Yehuda E, DeAngelis Ryan D, Velasco Brian, Nelson Charles L, Israelite Craig L
From the Penn Presbyterian Medical Center, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of Pennsylvania (Johnson, Barchick, Kerbel, DeAngelis, Velasco, Nelson, and Israelite), and The Hospital for Special Surgery, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery (Johnson), Philadelphia, PA.
J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2022 Oct 15;30(20):992-998. doi: 10.5435/JAAOS-D-22-00135. Epub 2022 Jun 29.
Controversy exists regarding the safety of simultaneous bilateral total knee arthroplasty (TKA) versus two TKA procedures staged months apart in patients with bilateral knee arthritis. Here, we investigated a third option: bilateral TKA staged 1 week apart. In this study, we examined the rate of complications in patients undergoing bilateral TKA staged at 1 week compared with longer time intervals.
A retrospective review of 351 consecutive patients undergoing bilateral TKA at our institution was conducted. Patients underwent a 1-week staged bilateral procedure with planned interim transfer to a subacute rehabilitation facility (short-staged) or two separate unilateral TKA procedures within 1 year (long-staged). Binary logistic regression was used to compare outcomes while controlling for year of surgery, patient age, body mass index, and Charlson Comorbidity Index.
Two hundred four short-staged and 147 long-staged bilateral TKA patients were included. The average interval between procedures in long-staged patients was 200.9 ± 95.9 days. Patients undergoing short-staged TKA had a higher Charlson Comorbidity Index (3.0 ± 1.5 versus 2.6 ± 1.5, P = 0.017) with no difference in preoperative hemoglobin ( P = 0.285) or body mass index ( P = 0.486). Regression analysis demonstrated that short-staged patients had a higher likelihood of requiring a blood transfusion (odds ratio 4.015, P = 0.005) but were less likely to return to the emergency department within 90 days (odds ratio 0.247, P = 0.001). No difference was observed in short-term complications ( P = 0.100), 90-day readmissions ( P = 0.250), or 1-year complications ( P = 0.418) between the groups.
Bilateral TKA staged at a 1-week interval is safe with a comparable complication rate with delayed staged TKA, but allows for a faster total recovery time.
Level III.
对于双侧膝关节关节炎患者,同期双侧全膝关节置换术(TKA)与间隔数月分期进行两次TKA手术的安全性存在争议。在此,我们研究了第三种选择:间隔1周分期进行双侧TKA。在本研究中,我们比较了间隔1周分期进行双侧TKA的患者与间隔更长时间分期进行双侧TKA的患者的并发症发生率。
对我院连续351例行双侧TKA的患者进行回顾性研究。患者接受间隔1周的分期双侧手术,计划中期转至亚急性康复机构(短分期),或在1年内进行两次单独的单侧TKA手术(长分期)。采用二元逻辑回归比较结果,同时控制手术年份、患者年龄、体重指数和查尔森合并症指数。
纳入204例短分期和147例长分期双侧TKA患者。长分期患者两次手术之间的平均间隔为200.9±95.9天。短分期TKA患者的查尔森合并症指数较高(3.0±1.5对2.6±1.5,P = 0.017),术前血红蛋白(P = 0.285)或体重指数(P = 0.486)无差异。回归分析表明,短分期患者需要输血的可能性更高(比值比4.015,P = 0.005),但在90天内返回急诊科的可能性较小(比值比0.247,P = 0.001)。两组在短期并发症(P = 0.100)、90天再入院率(P = 0.250)或1年并发症(P = 0.418)方面无差异。
间隔1周分期进行双侧TKA是安全的,并发症发生率与延迟分期TKA相当,但总恢复时间更快。
III级。