Tan Carolyn Michelle, Bernstein Michael, Raboud Janet, Mannino Benedetta, Tinmouth Jill
Department of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Toronto General Hospital Research Institute, University Health Network, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
J Can Assoc Gastroenterol. 2022 Mar 10;5(4):e57-e64. doi: 10.1093/jcag/gwac005. eCollection 2022 Aug.
Endoscopy units are being challenged to provide timely and quality care, despite limited resources and an ever-growing patient population. Decreasing procedure time is unlikely to create sufficient time savings and may compromise quality. Non-procedural factors, such as room turnover, are important contributors to efficiency and represent an ideal target for quality improvement efforts.
The objective of this quality improvement study was to identify practices that will improve endoscopy unit efficiency at our centre. The specific aims were to (a) understand practices at local hospitals that contribute to room turnover efficiency and (b) examine the magnitude and sources of variation in room turnover efficiency across endoscopists and nurses at our centre.
Interviews were conducted with team leads at five local hospitals. Routinely collected data from our centre were analyzed to understand the magnitude and variation in efficiency by provider and reasons for delays. Non-procedure time defined as 'patient 1 scope out' to 'patient 2 scope in' was our primary measure of efficiency.
Over the 12-month period, 750 outpatient procedures met inclusion criteria. Median non-procedure time was 19 min (interquartile range: 16-22 min). The variation attributable to endoscopists was 14.7% compared to 80.4% for unmeasured factors.
The variation that remains unexplained by our model suggests that unmeasured factors play a substantial role in endoscopy unit efficiency and that our current endoscopy records are not capturing important contributors to efficiency. The next phase will involve focus groups and direct observation with the goal of identifying these unmeasured factors.
尽管资源有限且患者数量不断增加,但内镜科室仍面临着提供及时且高质量护理的挑战。缩短操作时间不太可能节省足够的时间,并且可能会影响质量。诸如房间周转等非操作因素是效率的重要影响因素,也是质量改进工作的理想目标。
本质量改进研究的目的是确定能够提高我们中心内镜科室效率的做法。具体目标是:(a)了解当地医院有助于提高房间周转效率的做法;(b)研究我们中心内镜医师和护士在房间周转效率方面的差异程度及来源。
对五家当地医院的团队负责人进行了访谈。对从我们中心常规收集的数据进行分析,以了解不同提供者的效率差异程度及延误原因。从“患者1退出检查”到“患者2开始检查”的非操作时间是我们衡量效率的主要指标。
在这12个月期间,750例门诊手术符合纳入标准。非操作时间的中位数为19分钟(四分位间距:16 - 22分钟)。内镜医师导致的差异为14.7%,而未测量因素导致的差异为80.4%。
我们的模型无法解释的差异表明,未测量因素在内镜科室效率中起着重要作用,并且我们目前的内镜检查记录未能捕捉到影响效率的重要因素。下一阶段将开展焦点小组讨论和直接观察,目的是找出这些未测量因素。