儿童的生态焦虑:对气候变化意识对心理健康影响的范围综述
Eco-anxiety in children: A scoping review of the mental health impacts of the awareness of climate change.
作者信息
Léger-Goodes Terra, Malboeuf-Hurtubise Catherine, Mastine Trinity, Généreux Mélissa, Paradis Pier-Olivier, Camden Chantal
机构信息
Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Université de Sherbrooke, Sherbrooke, QC, Canada.
Department of Psychology, Bishop's University, Sherbrooke, QC, Canada.
出版信息
Front Psychol. 2022 Jul 25;13:872544. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2022.872544. eCollection 2022.
BACKGROUND
Youth are increasingly aware of the negative effects of climate change on the planet and human health, but this knowledge can often come with significant affective responses, such as psychological distress, anger, or despair. Experiencing major "negative" emotions, like worry, guilt, and hopelessness in anticipation of climate change has been identified with the term eco-anxiety. Emerging literature focuses on adults' experience; however, little is known about the ways in which children and youth experience eco-anxiety.
OBJECTIVES
The aim of this review was to: (1) identify the available evidence on the topic of eco-anxiety in children, (2) clarify the mental health consequences brought by the awareness of climate change in this population, and (3) identify knowledge gaps in the literature and considerations for future research.
METHODS
Given that the research on the topic of eco-anxiety in children is limited, that there are very few randomized controlled trials, and that the goal is not to analyze individual studies in-depth, a scoping review was used. Keywords pertaining to the themes of eco-anxiety, climate change and children (aged < 18 years) were used as search terms in five databases. Journal articles using qualitative and quantitative methods, as well as gray literature were examined by two independent reviewers. A descriptive-analytical method was used to chart the data that emerged from the literature. Eighteen articles were considered in the final analysis.
RESULTS
Evidence confirms that children experience affective responses and eco-anxiety in reaction to then awareness of climate change. Mental health outcomes include depression, anxiety, and extreme emotions like sadness, anger, and fear. Youth from vulnerable communities, like indigenous communities, or those who have strong ties to the land are often identified as being emotionally impacted by climate change. The literature analyzed also describes how children and youth are coping with eco-anxiety, including maladaptive (e.g., denial) and adaptive responses (such as constructive hope, used as a positive coping mechanism). Preliminary considerations for parents, teachers and educators, mental health care providers, school systems, adults and people of power include adding age-appropriate climate education to the school curriculum, considering youth's emotions, and promoting healthy coping through empowerment. Important gaps exist in the definition of eco-anxiety in youth, as various characterizations of this emerging concept are found across articles.
背景
青少年越来越意识到气候变化对地球和人类健康的负面影响,但这种认知往往伴随着重大的情感反应,如心理困扰、愤怒或绝望。预期气候变化时体验到诸如担忧、内疚和绝望等主要“负面”情绪已被用“生态焦虑”一词来描述。新兴文献聚焦于成年人的体验;然而,对于儿童和青少年体验生态焦虑的方式却知之甚少。
目的
本综述的目的是:(1)确定关于儿童生态焦虑主题的现有证据,(2)阐明该人群对气候变化的认知所带来的心理健康后果,以及(3)确定文献中的知识空白和对未来研究的考量。
方法
鉴于关于儿童生态焦虑主题的研究有限,随机对照试验极少,且目标并非深入分析个体研究,因此采用了范围综述。与生态焦虑、气候变化和儿童(年龄<18岁)主题相关的关键词被用作五个数据库的检索词。两名独立评审员对使用定性和定量方法的期刊文章以及灰色文献进行了审查。采用描述性分析方法对文献中出现的数据进行梳理。最终分析纳入了18篇文章。
结果
有证据证实,儿童在意识到气候变化时会产生情感反应和生态焦虑。心理健康结果包括抑郁、焦虑以及悲伤、愤怒和恐惧等极端情绪。来自弱势群体社区(如原住民社区)或与土地有紧密联系的青少年常被认为在情感上受到气候变化的影响。所分析的文献还描述了儿童和青少年应对生态焦虑的方式,包括适应不良的反应(如否认)和适应性反应(如建设性希望,作为一种积极的应对机制)。对于家长、教师和教育工作者、心理健康护理人员、学校系统、成年人及有权力者的初步考量包括在学校课程中增加适合年龄的气候教育、考虑青少年的情绪以及通过赋权促进健康应对。青少年生态焦虑的定义存在重要空白,因为在各文章中对这一新兴概念有不同的描述。