van Hoving Daniël Jacobus, Alenyo Annet Ngabirano, Komagum Faith, Lamprecht Hein
Division of Emergency Medicine, Stellenbosch University, Cape Town, South Africa.
Department of Emergency Medical Services, Ministry of Health, Kampala, Uganda.
Afr J Emerg Med. 2022 Dec;12(4):333-338. doi: 10.1016/j.afjem.2022.07.009. Epub 2022 Aug 4.
The African Federation of Emergency Medicine (AFEM) recommends the use of emergency point-of-care ultrasound (ePOCUS) as a core skill for health care practitioners in Africa. The study explored the use of ePOCUS by health care practitioners among AFEM members who work across Africa.
An anonymous online survey was distributed to individual members of AFEM and affiliated organisations. The questionnaire was tested by the AFEM Scientific Committee for potential content modifications prior to distribution. Summary statistics are presented.
Of the 220 participants that were analysed, 148 (67.3%) were using ePOCUS. The mean age was 36 years; 146 (66%) were male; and 198 (90%) obtained their primary medical qualification in Africa. In total, 168 (76%) were doctors, and most participants ( = 204, 93%) have worked in Africa during the last 5 years. Reasons for not using ePOCUS mainly related to lack of training and problems with ultrasound machines or consumables. Most ePOCUS users (116/148, 78%) attended courses with hands-on training, but only 65 (44%) participants were credentialed (by 18 different organizations). The median score for self-perceived level of ePOCUS skills was 75 in credentialed users versus 50 in those that were not credentialed. Ultrasound in trauma was the most frequently used module ( = 141, 99%), followed by focused cardiac assessment ( = 128, 90%) and thoracic (including lung) assessment ( = 128, 90.1%). The FASH-module (Focused Assessment with Sonography for HIV/TB) was the least used ( = 69, 49%).
Access barriers to ePOCUS training, mentorship, equipment and consumables are still relevant in Africa. The low credentialing rate and the potential discordance between local burden of disease and ePOCUS training requires further investigation.
非洲急诊医学联合会(AFEM)建议将急诊床旁超声检查(ePOCUS)作为非洲医疗从业者的一项核心技能。本研究探讨了在非洲各地工作的AFEM成员中的医疗从业者对ePOCUS的使用情况。
向AFEM的个人成员和附属组织发放了一份匿名在线调查问卷。该问卷在发放前由AFEM科学委员会进行测试,以便对潜在内容进行修改。给出了汇总统计数据。
在分析的220名参与者中,148名(67.3%)正在使用ePOCUS。平均年龄为36岁;146名(66%)为男性;198名(90%)在非洲获得了初级医学资格。总共有168名(76%)是医生,大多数参与者(n = 204,93%)在过去5年内在非洲工作过。不使用ePOCUS的原因主要与缺乏培训以及超声机器或耗材方面的问题有关。大多数ePOCUS使用者(116/148,78%)参加了有实践培训的课程,但只有65名(44%)参与者获得了资质认证(由18个不同组织颁发)。有资质认证的使用者自我感知的ePOCUS技能水平中位数为75分,而未获得资质认证的使用者为50分。创伤超声检查是最常用的模块(n = 141,99%),其次是心脏重点评估(n = 128,90%)和胸部(包括肺部)评估(n = 128,90.1%)。FASH模块(用于HIV/TB的超声重点评估)使用最少(n = 69,49%)。
在非洲,ePOCUS培训、指导、设备和耗材的获取障碍仍然存在。资质认证率低以及当地疾病负担与ePOCUS培训之间可能存在的不一致需要进一步调查。