School of Nursing, 26453Wenzhou Medical University, China.
Department of Endocrinology, 89657The First Affiliated Hospital of Wenzhou Medical University, China.
Health Informatics J. 2022 Jul-Sep;28(3):14604582221119950. doi: 10.1177/14604582221119950.
Numerous empirical studies have been carried out to explore factors of online health management continuance. However, results were not unified. We thus conducted a meta-analysis to identify influential factors and potential moderators. A systematic literature search was performed in nine databases (PubMed, Web of Science, the Cochrane Library, Ovid of JBI, CINAHL, Embase, CNKI, VIP, and CBM) published up to December 2020 in the English or Chinese language. Meta-analysis of combined effect size, heterogeneity, moderator analysis, publication bias assessment, and inter-rater reliability was conducted. Totally 41 studies and 12 pairwise relationships were identified. Confirmation, perceived usefulness, satisfaction, information quality, service quality, perceived ease of use, and trust were all critical predictors. Service type and age difference showed their moderating effects respectively. The perceived usefulness was more noteworthy in medical service than health and fitness service. The trust was more noteworthy in young adults. The results confirmed the validity and robustness of the Expectation Confirmation Model, Information Systems Success Model, and trust theory in online health management continuance. Moderators included but are not limited to age difference and service type. The elderly research in the healthcare context and other analytical methods such as qualitative comparative analysis should be applied in the future.
已经进行了许多实证研究来探索在线健康管理持续使用的因素。然而,结果并不统一。因此,我们进行了一项荟萃分析,以确定有影响力的因素和潜在的调节因素。系统检索了九个数据库(PubMed、Web of Science、Cochrane 图书馆、JBI 的 Ovid、CINAHL、Embase、CNKI、VIP 和 CBM)中截至 2020 年 12 月发表的英文或中文文献。对合并效应大小、异质性、调节分析、发表偏倚评估和评分者间信度进行了荟萃分析。总共确定了 41 项研究和 12 对关系。确认、感知有用性、满意度、信息质量、服务质量、感知易用性和信任都是关键的预测因素。服务类型和年龄差异分别显示出它们的调节作用。感知有用性在医疗服务中比在健康和健身服务中更为重要。信任在年轻成年人中更为重要。研究结果证实了期望确认模型、信息系统成功模型和信任理论在在线健康管理持续使用中的有效性和稳健性。调节因素包括但不限于年龄差异和服务类型。未来应该在医疗保健背景下对老年人进行研究,并应用其他分析方法,如定性比较分析。