Shim Youngbo, Phi Ji Hoon, Wang Kyu-Chang, Cho Byung-Kyu, Lee Ji Yeoun, Koh Eun Jung, Kim Kyung Hyun, Lee Eun Jung, Kim Ki Joong, Kim Seung-Ki
1Division of Pediatric Neurosurgery, Seoul National University Children's Hospital, Seoul National University College of Medicine, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
2Neuro-oncology Clinic, Center for Rare Cancers, National Cancer Center, Goyang, Republic of Korea.
J Neurosurg Pediatr. 2022 Sep 2;30(5):474-483. doi: 10.3171/2022.7.PEDS22299. Print 2022 Nov 1.
One-fourth of cerebral cavernous malformation (CCM) patients are children, but studies on these patients are scarce. This study aimed to identify the clinical presentation of pediatric CCM patients and to investigate clinical outcomes according to the treatment modalities applied on the basis of our institution's treatment strategy.
The authors performed a retrospective analysis of 124 pediatric CCM patients with a follow-up of more than 1 year from 2000 to 2019. They performed resection (n = 62) on lesions causing intractable seizure, rebleeding, or mass effect and observed the clinical courses of patients with lesions in deep or eloquent areas without persistent symptoms (n = 52). Radiosurgery (n = 10) was performed when the patient refused resection or strongly desired radiosurgery. The authors investigated the clinical characteristics, performance status (modified Rankin Scale [mRS] score), and rebleeding rate at the 1-year and last follow-up examinations and compared these among 3 groups classified on the basis of treatment applied. The authors evaluated seizure outcomes at the 1-year and last follow-up examinations for the surgery (n = 32) and observation (n = 17) groups. Finally, the authors drew cumulative incidence curves for the discontinuation of antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) for patients in the surgery (n = 30) and observation (n = 9) groups.
The 3 groups showed slight differences in initial symptoms, lesion locations, and rates of recent hemorrhage. The proportion of patients with improved mRS score at the 1-year follow-up was significantly greater in the surgery group than in the other groups (67% of the surgery group, 52% observation group, and 40% radiosurgery group; p = 0.078), as well as at the last follow-up (73% surgery group, 54% observation group, and 60% radiosurgery group; p = 0.097). The surgery group also had the lowest rebleeding rate during the follow-up period (2% surgery group, 11% observation group, and 20% radiosurgery group; p = 0.021). At the 1-year follow-up, the proportion of seizure-free patients without AEDs was significantly higher in the surgery group than the observation group (88% surgery group vs 53% observation group, p < 0.001), and similar results were obtained at the last follow-up (91% surgery group vs 56% observation group, p = 0.05). The 5-year AED-free rates for the surgery and observation groups were 94% and 50%, respectively, on the cumulative incidence curve (p = 0.049).
The clinical presentation of pediatric CCM patients was not significantly different from that of adult patients. Lesionectomy may be acceptable for pediatric CCM patients with indications of persistent seizures despite AED medications, rebleeding, and mass effects.
四分之一的脑海绵状血管畸形(CCM)患者为儿童,但针对这些患者的研究较少。本研究旨在明确儿童CCM患者的临床表现,并根据基于本机构治疗策略所应用的治疗方式来调查临床结局。
作者对2000年至2019年期间124例随访超过1年的儿童CCM患者进行了回顾性分析。他们对引起难治性癫痫、再出血或占位效应的病灶进行了切除(n = 62),并观察了深部或功能区有病灶但无持续症状的患者的临床病程(n = 52)。当患者拒绝切除或强烈希望进行放射外科治疗时,进行了放射外科治疗(n = 10)。作者调查了临床特征、功能状态(改良Rankin量表[mRS]评分)以及1年和末次随访时的再出血率,并在根据所应用治疗方式分类的3组之间进行了比较。作者评估了手术组(n = 32)和观察组(n = 17)在1年和末次随访时的癫痫结局。最后,作者绘制了手术组(n = 30)和观察组(n = 9)患者停用抗癫痫药物(AED)的累积发生率曲线。
3组在初始症状、病灶位置和近期出血率方面存在细微差异。手术组在1年随访时mRS评分改善的患者比例显著高于其他组(手术组为67%,观察组为52%,放射外科组为40%;p = 0.078),在末次随访时也是如此(手术组为73%,观察组为54%,放射外科组为60%;p = 0.097)。手术组在随访期间的再出血率也最低(手术组为2%,观察组为11%,放射外科组为20%;p = 0.021)。在1年随访时,手术组无AED且无癫痫发作的患者比例显著高于观察组(手术组为88%,观察组为53%,p < 0.001),末次随访时也得到了类似结果(手术组为91%,观察组为56%,p = 0.05)。在累积发生率曲线上,手术组和观察组的5年无AED率分别为94%和50%(p = 0.049)。
儿童CCM患者的临床表现与成人患者无显著差异。对于尽管使用了AED但仍有持续性癫痫、再出血和占位效应迹象的儿童CCM患者,病灶切除术可能是可以接受的。