Liver Failure Group, Institute for Liver and Digestive Health, UCL Medical School, Royal Free Hospital, London, UK; Department of Hepatology and Gastroenterology, Aarhus University Hospital, Aarhus, Denmark.
Liver Failure Group, Institute for Liver and Digestive Health, UCL Medical School, Royal Free Hospital, London, UK.
J Hepatol. 2023 Jan;78(1):123-132. doi: 10.1016/j.jhep.2022.08.034. Epub 2022 Sep 8.
BACKGROUND & AIMS: Individuals with cirrhosis discharged from hospital following acute decompensation are at high risk of new complications. This study aimed to assess the feasibility and potential clinical benefits of remote management of individuals with acutely decompensated cirrhosis using CirrhoCare®.
Individuals with cirrhosis with acute decompensation were followed up with CirrhoCare® and compared with contemporaneous matched controls, managed with standard follow-up. Commercially available monitoring devices were linked to the smartphone CirrhoCare® app, for daily recording of heart rate, blood pressure, weight, % body water, cognitive function (CyberLiver Animal Recognition Test [CL-ART] app), self-reported well-being, and intake of food, fluid, and alcohol. The app had 2-way patient-physician communication. Independent external adjudicators assessed the appropriateness of CirrhoCare®-based decisions.
Twenty individuals with cirrhosis were recruited to CirrhoCare® (mean age 59 ± 10 years, 14 male, alcohol-related cirrhosis [80%], mean model for end-stage liver disease-sodium [MELD-Na] score 16.1 ± 4.2) and were not statistically different to 20 contemporaneous controls. Follow-up was 10.1 ± 2.4 weeks. Fifteen individuals showed good engagement (≥4 readings/week), 2 moderate (2-3/week), and 3 poor (<2/week). In a usability questionnaire, the median score was ≥9 for all questions. Five CirrhoCare®-managed individuals had 8 readmissions over a median of 5 (IQR 3.5-11) days, and none required hospitalisation for >14 days. Sixteen other CirrhoCare®-guided patient contacts were made, leading to clinical interventions that prevented further progression. Appropriateness was confirmed by adjudicators. Controls had 13 readmissions in 8 individuals, lasting a median of 7 (IQR 3-15) days with 4 admissions of >14 days. They had 6 unplanned paracenteses compared with 1 in the CirrhoCare® group.
This study demonstrates that CirrhoCare® is feasible for community management of individuals with decompensated cirrhosis with good engagement and clinically relevant alerts to new decompensating events. CirrhoCare®-managed individuals have fewer and shorter readmissions justifying larger controlled clinical trials.
As the burden of cirrhosis grows worldwide, increasing demands are being placed on limited healthcare resources, necessitating the adoption of more sustainable care models that allow for at-home patient management. The CirrhoCare® management system was developed to fill this care gap, deploying a novel combination of hardware, apps, and algorithms, to monitor and intervene in individuals at risk of new decompensation. This study highlights the possibility of reducing hospital readmissions for cirrhosis by optimising specialist community care, reducing the need for interventions such as paracentesis, while providing a more sustainable care pathway that is acceptable to patients. However, given the pilot and non-randomised nature of this study, the outcomes require further validation in a larger randomised controlled trial, to assess both clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness. Moreover, the data generated will also facilitate data modelling and further research to refine the CirrhoCare® algorithms to increase their detection sensitivity and utility.
急性失代偿出院后的肝硬化患者存在新并发症的高风险。本研究旨在评估使用 CirrhoCare®对急性失代偿肝硬化患者进行远程管理的可行性和潜在临床益处。
使用 CirrhoCare®对急性失代偿肝硬化患者进行随访,并与同期匹配的对照组进行比较,对照组采用标准随访。商业上可用的监测设备与智能手机 CirrhoCare®应用程序相连,用于日常记录心率、血压、体重、%体水、认知功能(CyberLiver 动物识别测试 [CL-ART]应用程序)、自我报告的幸福感以及食物、液体和酒精的摄入量。该应用程序具有医患双向交流功能。独立的外部裁判评估基于 CirrhoCare®的决策的适当性。
CirrhoCare®招募了 20 名肝硬化患者(平均年龄 59 ± 10 岁,14 名男性,酒精性肝硬化 [80%],平均终末期肝病模型钠 [MELD-Na]评分 16.1 ± 4.2),与 20 名同期对照组没有统计学差异。随访时间为 10.1 ± 2.4 周。15 名患者表现出良好的参与度(每周≥4 次读数),2 名患者表现出中度参与度(每周 2-3 次),3 名患者表现出较差的参与度(每周<2 次)。在用户使用情况问卷调查中,所有问题的中位数评分均≥9。5 名 CirrhoCare®管理的患者在中位数为 5(IQR 3.5-11)天内发生了 8 次再入院,且无 1 例住院时间超过 14 天。另外还有 16 次其他 CirrhoCare®指导的患者联系,采取了临床干预措施,防止了病情进一步恶化。裁判确认了适当性。对照组中有 8 名患者发生了 13 次再入院,中位时间为 7(IQR 3-15)天,其中 4 次住院时间超过 14 天。他们有 6 次非计划性放腹水,而 CirrhoCare®组只有 1 次。
本研究表明,CirrhoCare®可用于社区管理失代偿性肝硬化患者,患者参与度高,且有临床相关的新失代偿事件警报。CirrhoCare®管理的患者再入院次数和时间更短,这证明了更大规模的对照临床试验是合理的。
随着全球肝硬化负担的增加,对有限的医疗资源的需求不断增加,因此需要采用更可持续的护理模式,允许患者在家中接受管理。CirrhoCare®管理系统的开发就是为了填补这一护理空白,它结合了硬件、应用程序和算法,以监测和干预有新失代偿风险的患者。这项研究强调了通过优化专科社区护理来减少肝硬化患者的住院再入院率的可能性,减少了像放腹水这样的干预措施的需要,同时提供了一种更可持续的患者可接受的护理途径。然而,鉴于本研究的试点和非随机性质,其结果需要在更大的随机对照试验中进一步验证,以评估临床效果和成本效益。此外,所产生的数据还将促进数据建模和进一步研究,以提高 CirrhoCare®算法的检测灵敏度和实用性。