Salomone Fabio, Di Costanzo Fabrizio, Pecoraro Giovanna, Viscardi Giuseppe, Viggiano Angela, Napolitano Fabiana, Santaniello Antonio, Formisano Luigi, Bianco Roberto, Servetto Alberto
Department of Clinical Medicine and Surgery, University of Naples Federico II, Naples, Italy.
Department of Pneumology and Oncology, AORN Ospedali dei Colli-Monaldi, Naples, Italy.
Lung Cancer. 2022 Dec;174:36-44. doi: 10.1016/j.lungcan.2022.10.003. Epub 2022 Oct 19.
Major associations of medical oncologists remark that novel anticancer treatments should guarantee improvement of survival outcomes as well as of patients' quality of life (QoL). Herein, we investigated QoL assessment and reporting in phase III randomized controlled trials (RCTs) testing new drugs in metastatic non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC), published between 2010 and 2021. We selected 172 RCTs for further analysis. Only 2/172 (1.2%) trial included QoL among primary study endpoints. Of note, 40/172 (23.3%) trials did not include QoL assessment among endpoints. The majority of RCTs (102/172, 59.3%) did not report QoL results in primary publications. Particularly, RCTs testing immunotherapy, target therapy and chemotherapy did not disclose QoL data in primary publications in 97.0%, 51.5% and 46.5% of cases, respectively. Next, we found that only 43/95 (45.3%) positive studies reported QoL results in primary articles. Of the 102 trials missing QoL data in primary manuscripts, only 21 (20.6%) disclosed QoL results in a secondary publication. Finally, we found a common fail in adherence to CONSORT-PROs items in publications reporting QoL results. In summary, our study reveals a relevant inadequate assessment and under-reporting of QoL in RCTs of novel systemic treatments for patients with metastatic NSCLC.
医学肿瘤学家的主要协会指出,新型抗癌治疗应确保生存结果以及患者生活质量(QoL)得到改善。在此,我们调查了2010年至2021年间发表的、在转移性非小细胞肺癌(NSCLC)中测试新药的III期随机对照试验(RCT)中的生活质量评估和报告情况。我们选择了172项RCT进行进一步分析。只有2/172(1.2%)的试验将生活质量纳入主要研究终点。值得注意的是,40/172(23.3%)的试验在终点中未纳入生活质量评估。大多数RCT(102/172,59.3%)在主要出版物中未报告生活质量结果。特别是,测试免疫疗法、靶向疗法和化疗的RCT在主要出版物中分别有97.0%、51.5%和46.5%的病例未披露生活质量数据。接下来,我们发现只有43/95(45.3%)的阳性研究在主要文章中报告了生活质量结果。在102项在主要手稿中缺少生活质量数据的试验中,只有21项(20.6%)在二次出版物中披露了生活质量结果。最后,我们发现在报告生活质量结果的出版物中,普遍存在未遵守CONSORT-PROs项目的情况。总之,我们的研究揭示了在转移性NSCLC患者新型全身治疗的RCT中,生活质量评估存在相关不足且报告不充分。