Irawan Benny, Yulia Rena
Sultan Ageng Tirtayasa University, Kabupaten Serang, Banten, Indonesia.
J Public Health Res. 2022 Oct 20;11(4):22799036221115769. doi: 10.1177/22799036221115769. eCollection 2022 Oct.
This research aims to present a legal history of the prisoners' treatment in global crises along with presenting an overview of prisoners' treatment during Covid-19 in view of International Humanitarian Laws. Using the formative research method with a conceptual approach and statute approach, data was gathered from various legal documents related to prisoners' health laws linked to legal purpose theories. This study further explains the need to treat old age prisoners on a priority basis and to what extent international health organizations are making efforts to establish criteria to vaccinate this societal segment. The international regulatory framework was deeply analyzed to draw conclusions and recommendations along with WHO efforts. It was revealed that there exist adequate laws regarding priority health treatment of the prisoners in crises times but existed an enormous need to highlight and address the sensitive humanitarian issue. Additionally, WHO and other international organizations have also revised the international laws during Covid-19 to treat the prisoners. However, there is an immense need to devise explicit regulations regarding the accessibility of the vaccine to all the groups of society, including prisoners. The provision of a detailed overview of international laws and treaties regarding prisoners' priority health treatment is a major advance of this research. Further recommendations for the developed and developing nations and future research directions are suggested.
本研究旨在呈现全球危机期间囚犯待遇的法律史,并结合国际人道法,概述新冠疫情期间的囚犯待遇。采用概念法和法规法相结合的实证研究方法,从与囚犯健康法相关的各种法律文件中收集数据,这些文件与法律目的理论相关。本研究进一步解释了优先对待老年囚犯的必要性,以及国际卫生组织在制定该社会群体疫苗接种标准方面所做的努力程度。深入分析了国际监管框架,以得出结论并提出建议,同时考虑了世卫组织的努力。结果显示,危机时期有足够的法律规定囚犯的优先医疗待遇,但迫切需要突出并解决这一敏感的人道主义问题。此外,世卫组织和其他国际组织在新冠疫情期间也修订了相关国际法以对待囚犯。然而,迫切需要制定明确的法规,确保包括囚犯在内的所有社会群体都能获得疫苗。详细概述有关囚犯优先医疗待遇的国际法和条约是本研究的一项重大进展。本研究还为发达国家和发展中国家提出了进一步建议以及未来的研究方向。