Delfosse C, Marquillier T, Ndoye S, Cousson P-Y, Hennequin M, Catteau C
Department of Paediatric Dentistry, University of Lille, UFR3S-Odontologie, Odontologie Pédiatrique, 59000, Lille, France.
CHU Lille, Service d'Odontologie, 59000, Lille, France.
Eur Arch Paediatr Dent. 2023 Feb;24(1):105-116. doi: 10.1007/s40368-022-00764-0. Epub 2022 Oct 31.
The main purpose of this study was to assess the effect of a root canal treatment (RCT) practical simulation-based session using 3D printed primary molars on the self-confidence of fourth-year undergraduate dental students. Our study was also designed to explore student experiences with both manual and rotary RCT procedures and to investigate the association between the self-confidence in undertaking an RCT and the quality of the RCT.
Student global self-confidence in undertaking an RCT on a healthy, cooperative child aged 4-5 years was evaluated 2 h before, 1 month after, and 11 months after the simulation training session. Once each instrumental procedure had been completed, the students were also asked to score the level of confidence (specific self-confidence) they felt regarding the use of RP and MP. After each training session, the quality of the RCT was radiographically evaluated by two trained, independent investigators.
Overall, student global self-confidence in undertaking an RCT increased significantly immediately after the practical session and remained stable for the ensuing eleven months. The students declared a clear preference for RP and were more self-confident in undertaking an RCT after RP than after MP. The proportion of RCTs considered of good quality was the same for the manual (31.5%) and rotary (30.3%) procedures.
Simulation training is a good way to train dental students who are confident in undertaking RCTs. However, confidence is not directly related to competence. Teachers should be encouraged to develop a comprehensive simulation training program, including feedback, debriefing, and repetitions.
本研究的主要目的是评估使用3D打印乳牙进行基于根管治疗(RCT)实践模拟课程对四年级牙科本科学生自信心的影响。我们的研究还旨在探索学生在手动和旋转RCT程序方面的经验,并调查进行RCT的自信心与RCT质量之间的关联。
在模拟训练课程前2小时、1个月后和11个月后,评估学生对4至5岁健康、合作儿童进行RCT的总体自信心。每次完成一项器械操作后,还要求学生对他们在使用旋转器械(RP)和手动器械(MP)时的自信程度(特定自信心)进行评分。每次训练课程后,由两名经过培训的独立研究人员对RCT的质量进行影像学评估。
总体而言,学生在实践课程后立即进行RCT的总体自信心显著提高,并在随后的十一个月内保持稳定。学生们明确表示更喜欢RP,并且在使用RP进行RCT后比使用MP后更自信。手动操作(31.5%)和旋转操作(30.3%)的RCT被认为质量良好的比例相同。
模拟训练是培训有信心进行RCT的牙科学生的好方法。然而,信心与能力并不直接相关。应鼓励教师制定全面的模拟训练计划,包括反馈、汇报和重复训练。