Zhu Yunyi, Lian Boyue, Wang Yuan, Miller Christopher, Bales Clare, Fletcher John, Yao Lina, Waite T David
UNSW Centre for Transformational Environmental Technologies (CTET), Yixing, Jiangsu, China; Water Research Centre, School of Civil and Environmental Engineering, UNSW Sydney, Australia.
Water Research Centre, School of Civil and Environmental Engineering, UNSW Sydney, Australia.
Water Res. 2022 Dec 1;227:119349. doi: 10.1016/j.watres.2022.119349. Epub 2022 Nov 10.
Membrane Capacitive Deionization (MCDI) is a promising electrochemical technique for water desalination. Previous studies have confirrmed the effectiveness of MCDI in removing contaminants from brackish groundwaters, especially in remote areas where electricity is scarce. However, as with other water treatment technologies, performance deterioration of the MCDI system still occurs, hindering the stability of long-term operation. Herein, a machine learning (ML) modelling framework and various ML models were developed to (i) investigate the performance deterioration due particularly to insufficient charging/discharging of the electrode caused by accumulation of ions and electrode scaling and (ii) optimise MCDI operating parameters such that the impacts of these deleterious effects on unit performance were minimized. The ML models developed in this work exhibited a prediction accuracy of cycle time with average mean absolute percentage error (MAPE) values of 16.82% and 16.09% after 30-fold cross validation for Random Forest (RF) and Multilayer Perceptron (MLP) models respectively. The pre-trained ML model predicted different declining trends of water production for two different operating conditions and provided corresponding recommendations on frequencies of chemical cleaning. A case study on the adjustment of operating parameters using the results suggested by the optimization ML model was conducted. The model validation results showed that the overall water production and water recovery of the system using the cycle-based optimized process control parameters (SCN 1) exceeds the MCDI system performance under three fixed parameter settings that were used at each stage of SCN 1 by 1.78% to 4.48% and 2.95% to 9.46%, respectively. Permutation-based and Shapley additive explanation (SHAP) coefficients were also employed for variable importance (VIMP) analysis to uncover the "black-box" nature of the ML models and to better understand the various features' contributions to overall MCDI system performance.
膜电容去离子化(MCDI)是一种很有前景的用于水脱盐的电化学技术。先前的研究已证实MCDI在去除微咸地下水中的污染物方面是有效的,特别是在电力稀缺的偏远地区。然而,与其他水处理技术一样,MCDI系统的性能仍会恶化,这阻碍了长期运行的稳定性。在此,开发了一个机器学习(ML)建模框架和各种ML模型,以(i)研究特别是由于离子积累和电极结垢导致的电极充电/放电不足所引起的性能恶化,以及(ii)优化MCDI操作参数,从而使这些有害影响对单元性能的影响最小化。在这项工作中开发的ML模型在对随机森林(RF)和多层感知器(MLP)模型进行30折交叉验证后,分别显示出循环时间的预测准确率,平均平均绝对百分比误差(MAPE)值为16.82%和16.09%。预训练的ML模型预测了两种不同操作条件下产水量的不同下降趋势,并给出了化学清洗频率的相应建议。使用优化ML模型建议的结果进行了操作参数调整的案例研究。模型验证结果表明,使用基于循环的优化过程控制参数(SCN 1)的系统的总产水量和水回收率分别比在SCN 1的每个阶段使用固定参数设置的MCDI系统性能高出1.78%至4.48%和2.95%至9.46%。基于排列和夏普利附加解释(SHAP)系数也用于变量重要性(VIMP)分析,以揭示ML模型的“黑箱”性质,并更好地理解各种特征对MCDI系统整体性能的贡献。