研究微塑料采集技术的演变。
Investigating the evolution of the technologies for collecting microplastics.
机构信息
University of Bergamo, Department of Management, Information and Production Engineering, Via Marconi 5, 24044 Dalmine, Italy.
Associate Professor, University of Bergamo, Department of Management, Information and Production Engineering, Via Marconi 5, 24044 Dalmine, Italy.
出版信息
J Environ Manage. 2023 Jan 15;326(Pt B):116710. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2022.116710. Epub 2022 Nov 17.
To stop the dispersion of microplastics in the ecosystem, many technologies for collecting them were designed, tested and developed in the last period. However, a complete and exhaustive comparison of these technologies to guide in the choice and/or in the development of the most suitable appropriate one is missing in the literature. This study investigates the presence of some known technological trends, deriving from the TRIZ (Russian acronym for "Theory of Inventive Problem Solving") in the behaviour (i.e. the operating principle) of these technologies. To do this, a systematic methodology was followed, which has a general value and consists in analysing the patents relating to these technologies through various bibliometric indexes (i.e. Innovation index, Emergence Score index, Independent Claims index and Technology Cycle Time index). In general, the obtained results did not reveal a clearly identifiable ranking of the behaviour which was unanimously confirmed by all the considered bibliometric indexes. In addition, the average of the scores of the different indexes associated with the different behaviours equalized their differences. However, these results are mainly due to the markedly different evaluations obtained by the Emergence Score index compared to those of the other indexes. From the comparison of the results with the evolutionary trends, it emerged that the operative zone reduction trend was the most confirmed, while the technical system dematerialization was the least confirmed by the bibliometric analysis of all the indexes. In particular, the ranking of the behaviours provided by the Innovation index best confirmed all the evolutionary trends, while that of the Emergence Score index was the worst. In conclusion, this study confirmed the adherence of the development that technologies for collecting microplastics are following to the evolutionary trends through bibliometric analysis: this sequence places magnetic technologies in first place, followed by chemical, fluid dynamics, dynamic mechanics and static mechanics. The analysis of the performances declared in the patents substantially confirms this result.
为了阻止微塑料在生态系统中的扩散,在过去的一段时间里,设计、测试和开发了许多收集微塑料的技术。然而,文献中缺少对这些技术的全面、详尽的比较,以指导选择和/或开发最合适的技术。本研究调查了一些已知的技术趋势在这些技术的行为(即操作原理)中的存在,这些技术趋势源自 TRIZ(俄语缩写为“发明问题解决理论”)。为此,采用了一种系统的方法,该方法具有普遍价值,包括通过各种文献计量指标(即创新指数、出现得分指数、独立权利要求指数和技术周期时间指数)分析与这些技术相关的专利。总的来说,获得的结果并没有显示出行为的明确可识别排名,这一排名得到了所有考虑到的文献计量指标的一致确认。此外,与不同行为相关的不同指标的得分平均值平均化了它们之间的差异。然而,这些结果主要是由于出现得分指数获得的明显不同的评估与其他指数的评估不同所致。通过将结果与进化趋势进行比较,发现操作区域缩小趋势是最被确认的,而技术系统去物质化趋势是最不被文献计量分析确认的所有指标。特别是,创新指数提供的行为排名最能确认所有的进化趋势,而出现得分指数的排名最差。总之,本研究通过文献计量分析证实了收集微塑料技术的发展与进化趋势的一致性:这种顺序将磁技术置于首位,其次是化学、流体动力学、动态力学和静态力学。专利中声明的性能分析基本上证实了这一结果。