Mangelkramer Delia
Chair of Innovation Management, Freie Universität Berlin, Berlin, Germany.
Front Res Metr Anal. 2022 Nov 24;7:1057378. doi: 10.3389/frma.2022.1057378. eCollection 2022.
Analyzing the impact of a sustainability agenda in research and innovation on system transition is a critical research topic. This literature stream aims to examine how research and innovation can deal with wicked-problems at a dynamic system level to create more sustainable future systems. However, this study addresses two main issues in the current sustainability transition literature. First, the literature to date offers little insight into concrete implications for the management of innovation processes at the organizational level. Second, sustainability is often addressed as desirable. While the concept of Sustainable Innovation (SI) can valuably contribute in addressing the first issue by providing essential features to analyze business management procedures and their broader implications on socio-technical systems, it falls short in addressing the second issue. Essential aspects of sustainability, such as the responsibility for potential future trade-offs through innovation, are not strategically integrated into the current framework. This study argues that without strategic integration of responsibility, there is a risk of contributing to a partially-sustainable-"irresponsible"-socio-technical system change as a result of business innovation activities. Therefore, an extended innovation process model for sustainability to embed responsibility at the core of innovation activities is required. For this purpose, the framework of Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI) is utilized. This paper reports on findings from a systematic literature review of a representative sample of empirical studies from the SI and RRI literature. Thereby, the goal was to extend the understanding of management opportunities within innovation processes for sustainability through the implementation of RRI principles, in order to create sustainable socio-technical systems.
分析研究与创新中的可持续发展议程对系统转型的影响是一个关键的研究课题。这一文献流派旨在探讨研究与创新如何在动态系统层面应对棘手问题,以创造更具可持续性的未来系统。然而,本研究解决了当前可持续发展转型文献中的两个主要问题。首先,迄今为止的文献对组织层面创新过程管理的具体影响鲜有见解。其次,可持续性往往被视为是可取的。虽然可持续创新(SI)概念通过提供分析商业管理程序及其对社会技术系统更广泛影响的基本特征,能够在解决第一个问题方面做出有价值的贡献,但在解决第二个问题上却有所不足。可持续性的基本方面,如通过创新对未来潜在权衡的责任,并未被战略性地纳入当前框架。本研究认为,如果没有责任的战略整合,商业创新活动可能会导致部分可持续的“不负责任的”社会技术系统变革。因此,需要一个扩展的可持续性创新过程模型,将责任嵌入创新活动的核心。为此,采用了负责任研究与创新(RRI)框架。本文报告了对来自SI和RRI文献的实证研究代表性样本进行系统文献综述的结果。从而,目标是通过实施RRI原则,扩展对可持续性创新过程中管理机会的理解,以创建可持续的社会技术系统。