Department of Urology, University of Arizona College of Medicine, 1501 N. Campbell Ave, PO Box 245077, Tucson, AZ, 85724, USA.
Department of Urology, Mayo Clinic Arizona, 5777 E. Mayo Blvd, Phoenix, AZ, 85054, USA.
Urolithiasis. 2022 Dec 12;51(1):15. doi: 10.1007/s00240-022-01373-8.
Kidney stone cultures can be beneficial in identifying bacteria not detected in urine, yet how stone cultures are performed among endourologists, under what conditions, and by what laboratory methods remain largely unknown. Stone cultures are not addressed by current clinical guidelines. A comprehensive REDCap electronic survey sought responses from directed (n = 20) and listserv elicited (n = 108) endourologists specializing in kidney stone disease. Questions included which clinical scenarios prompt a stone culture order, how results influence post-operative antibiotics, and what microbiology lab protocols exist at each institution with respect to processing and resulting stone cultures. Logistic regression statistical analysis determined what factors were associated with performing stone cultures. Of 128 unique responses, 11% identified as female and the mean years of practicing was 16 (range 1-46). A specific 'stone culture' order was available to only 50% (64/128) of those surveyed, while 32% (41/128) reported culturing stone by placing a urine culture order. The duration of antibiotics given for a positive stone culture varied, with 4-7 days (46%) and 8-14 days (21%) the most reported. More years in practice was associated with fewer stone cultures ordered, while higher annual volume of percutaneous nephrolithotomy was associated with ordering more stone cultures (p < 0.01). Endourologists have differing practice patterns with respect to ordering stone cultures and utilizing the results to guide post-operative antibiotics. With inconsistent microbiology lab stone culture protocols across multiple institutions, more uniform processing is needed for future studies to assess the clinical benefit of stone cultures and direct future guidelines.
肾结石培养有助于鉴定尿液中未检测到的细菌,但目前仍不清楚泌尿科医生如何进行结石培养、在何种情况下进行以及采用何种实验室方法进行。现行临床指南并未涉及结石培养。一项全面的 REDCap 电子调查向专门从事肾结石疾病的定向(n=20)和列表服务(n=108)泌尿科医生征求了意见。问题包括哪些临床情况提示需要进行结石培养,结果如何影响术后抗生素的使用,以及每个机构在处理和产生结石培养方面存在哪些微生物学实验室方案。逻辑回归统计分析确定了哪些因素与进行结石培养有关。在 128 个唯一回复中,11%的人是女性,平均从业年限为 16 年(范围 1-46 年)。只有 50%(64/128)的受访者可以获得特定的“结石培养”医嘱,而 32%(41/128)的人报告通过放置尿液培养医嘱来进行结石培养。阳性结石培养所给予的抗生素持续时间不同,4-7 天(46%)和 8-14 天(21%)是最常见的报告时间。从业年限越长,下达的结石培养医嘱越少,而每年经皮肾镜碎石术的数量越多,下达的结石培养医嘱就越多(p<0.01)。泌尿科医生在进行结石培养和使用结果来指导术后抗生素使用方面存在不同的实践模式。由于多个机构的微生物学实验室结石培养方案不一致,需要更统一的处理方法,以便进行未来的研究来评估结石培养的临床益处,并为未来的指南提供指导。