McNutt Markey C, Foreman Nathan, Gotway Garrett
UT Southwestern Medical Center Dallas Texas USA.
RehabMetrics Colleyville Texas USA.
Mov Disord Clin Pract. 2022 Nov 22;10(1):109-114. doi: 10.1002/mdc3.13612. eCollection 2023 Jan.
Arginase 1 Deficiency (ARG1-D) is a rare autosomal recessive urea cycle disorder (UCD) characterized by pathologic elevation of plasma arginine and debilitating manifestations. Based on clinical commonalities and low disease awareness, ARG1-D can be diagnosed as hereditary spastic paraplegia (HSP), leading to treatment delays.
A Hispanic woman with unremarkable medical history experienced progressive lower-limb spasticity in her 20s and received a diagnosis of HSP. She developed significant gait abnormalities and is unable to walk without assistance. More recently, two Hispanic brothers with childhood-onset manifestations including lower-limb spasticity, developmental delays, and seizures presented with suspected HSP. All three patients were ultimately diagnosed with ARG1-D based on plasma arginine several-fold above normal levels and loss-of-function variants. Disease progression occurred before ARG1-D was correctly diagnosed.
Retrospective analyses demonstrate that diagnostic delays in ARG1-D are common and can be lengthy. Because of clinical similarities between ARG1-D and HSP, such as insidious onset and progressive spasticity, accurate diagnosis of ARG1-D is challenging. Timely ARG1-D diagnosis is critical because this UCD is a treatable genetic cause of progressive lower-limb spasticity.
Arginase 1 Deficiency should be considered in HSP differential diagnosis until biochemically/genetically excluded, and should be routinely included in HSP gene panels.
精氨酸酶1缺乏症(ARG1-D)是一种罕见的常染色体隐性尿素循环障碍(UCD),其特征为血浆精氨酸病理性升高和使人衰弱的症状。基于临床共性和疾病认知度低,ARG1-D可能被诊断为遗传性痉挛性截瘫(HSP),从而导致治疗延误。
一名无明显病史的西班牙裔女性在20多岁时出现进行性下肢痉挛,并被诊断为HSP。她出现了明显的步态异常,没有帮助无法行走。最近,两名患有儿童期发病症状(包括下肢痉挛、发育迟缓及癫痫发作)的西班牙裔兄弟疑似患有HSP。基于血浆精氨酸水平高于正常水平数倍及功能缺失变异,所有三名患者最终被诊断为ARG1-D。在ARG1-D被正确诊断之前疾病已经进展。
回顾性分析表明,ARG1-D的诊断延误很常见且可能持续很长时间。由于ARG1-D与HSP之间存在临床相似性,如隐匿起病和进行性痉挛,准确诊断ARG1-D具有挑战性。及时诊断ARG1-D至关重要,因为这种尿素循环障碍是进行性下肢痉挛的可治疗遗传病因。
在通过生化/基因排除之前,遗传性痉挛性截瘫的鉴别诊断中应考虑精氨酸酶1缺乏症,并且应常规纳入遗传性痉挛性截瘫基因检测板中。