Department of Physiology and Biophysics, Chicago Medical School, North Chicago, Illinois, United States.
Am J Physiol Cell Physiol. 2023 Apr 1;324(4):C910-C926. doi: 10.1152/ajpcell.00434.2022. Epub 2023 Jan 30.
"I don't know the question, but sex is definitely the answer!," was a Woody Allen quote cited by Fuller and Insel in an Editorial Comment in 2013 on the importance of cell sex in submissions to , and in biomedical research in general. The notion that cell sex is important is axiomatic in studies on prostate cancer (LnCAP) or placental physiology (BeWo). Indeed, most researchers are aware that HeLa cells are female cervical derived, and CHO are female hamster ovary cells, yet beyond those well-known examples, it would be fair to assume that the sex of cells derived from kidney, lung, or liver, for example, is given cursory, if any thought. In the end, what possible impact could the presence or absence of a Y chromosome have on protein trafficking in a nonreproductive tissue, such as a pancreatic β cell? However, this approach to cell, and indeed organismal physiology, seems to be in conflict with accumulating data, that show that far from being irrelevant, genes expressed off sex chromosomes have a broad-ranging impact on cells as diverse as neurons and renal cells. Moreover, it is also the policy of that the source of all cells used (species, sex, etc.) should be clearly indicated when submitting an article for publication (https://journals.physiology.org/author-info.manuscript-composition). In 2013, we wrote a review examining how faithfully such requirements were adhered to in submissions to . Nearly a decade later, it seems fitting to revisit the topic and ask if any improvements have been made in the description of cells and cell lines used in publications submitted to .
“我不知道这个问题,但性肯定是答案!”这是伍迪·艾伦(Woody Allen)在 2013 年的一篇社论评论中引用的一句话,该评论强调了细胞性别在 投稿和一般生物医学研究中的重要性。细胞性别很重要,这一观点在前列腺癌(LnCAP)或胎盘生理学(BeWo)的研究中是不言而喻的。事实上,大多数研究人员都知道 HeLa 细胞是源自女性宫颈的,CHO 是源自雌性仓鼠卵巢的细胞,但除了这些众所周知的例子之外,可以公平地假设,例如,从肾脏、肺或肝脏中获得的细胞的性别,如果有任何想法,也只是粗略考虑。最终,Y 染色体的存在与否如何影响非生殖组织(如胰腺β细胞)中的蛋白质运输?然而,这种对细胞乃至机体生理学的方法似乎与越来越多的数据相冲突,这些数据表明,远远不是无关紧要的,性染色体上表达的基因对神经元和肾细胞等各种细胞都有广泛的影响。此外,这也是 的政策,即在提交文章供出版时(https://journals.physiology.org/author-info.manuscript-composition),应清楚注明所有使用细胞的来源(物种、性别等)。2013 年,我们写了一篇评论文章,检查了在提交给 的文章中,这些要求的遵守情况有多忠实。近十年后,重新审视这个话题,询问在提交给 的出版物中使用的细胞和细胞系的描述是否有任何改进,似乎是合适的。