Division of Vascular Surgery, Department of Surgery, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, CA.
Division of Vascular Surgery, Department of Surgery, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, CA.
J Vasc Surg. 2023 Jun;77(6):1797-1802. doi: 10.1016/j.jvs.2023.01.198. Epub 2023 Feb 8.
Survey data suggests that surgical residents spend 20% to 30% of training time using the electronic medical record (EMR), raising concerns about burnout and insufficient operative experience. We characterize trainee EMR activity in the vascular surgery service of a quaternary care center to identify modifiable factors associated with high EMR use.
Resident activity while on the vascular surgery service was queried from the EMR. Weekends and holidays were excluded to focus on typical staffing periods. Variables including daily time spent, post-graduate year (PGY), remote access via mobile device or personal laptop, and patient census including operative caseload were extracted. Univariate analysis was performed with t tests and χ tests where appropriate. We then fit a linear mixed-effects model with normalized daily EMR time as the outcome variable, random slopes for resident and patient census, and fixed effects of PGY level, academic year, and fractional time spent using remote access.
EMR activity for 53 residents from July 2015 to June 2019 was included. The mean daily EMR usage was 1.6 hours, ranging from 3.6 hours per day in PGY1 residents to 1.1 hours in PGY4 to 5 residents. Across all PGYs, the most time-consuming EMR activities were chart review (43.0%-46.6%) and notes review (22.4%-27.0%). In the linear mixed-effects model, increased patient census was associated with increased daily EMR usage (Coefficient = 0.61, P-value < .001). Resident seniority (Coefficient = -1.2, P-value < .001) and increased remote access (Coefficient = -0.44, P-value < .001) were associated with reduced daily EMR usage. Over the study period, total EMR usage decreased significantly from the 2015/2016 academic year to the 2018/2019 academic year (mean difference, 2.4 hours vs 1.78; P-value < .001).
In an audit of EMR activity logs on a vascular surgery service, mean EMR time was 1.6 hours a day, which is lower than survey estimates. Resident seniority and remote access utilization were associated with reduced time spent on the EMR, independent of patient census. Although increasing EMR accessibility via mobile devices and personal computers have been hypothesized to contribute to poor work-life balance, our study suggests a possible time-saving effect by enabling expedient access for data review, which constitutes the majority of resident EMR activity. Further research in other institutions and specialties is needed for external validation and exploring implications for resident wellness initiatives.
调查数据表明,外科住院医师在培训期间有 20%至 30%的时间用于使用电子病历(EMR),这引发了对倦怠和手术经验不足的担忧。我们对一家四级保健中心的血管外科服务中的学员 EMR 活动进行了描述,以确定与高 EMR 使用相关的可改变因素。
从 EMR 中查询住院医师在血管外科服务期间的活动情况。排除周末和节假日,以关注典型的人员配备时段。提取的变量包括每天花费的时间、住院医师培训年限(PGY)、通过移动设备或个人笔记本远程访问以及包括手术病例量在内的患者普查。适当情况下进行 t 检验和 χ 检验的单变量分析。然后,我们拟合了一个线性混合效应模型,将标准化的每日 EMR 时间作为因变量,居民和患者普查的随机斜率,以及 PGY 水平、学术年度和使用远程访问的时间分数的固定效应。
纳入了 2015 年 7 月至 2019 年 6 月期间 53 名住院医师的 EMR 活动情况。平均每日 EMR 使用时间为 1.6 小时,PGY1 住院医师每天使用 3.6 小时,PGY4 至 5 住院医师每天使用 1.1 小时。在所有 PGY 中,最耗时的 EMR 活动是图表审查(43.0%-46.6%)和记录审查(22.4%-27.0%)。在线性混合效应模型中,患者普查的增加与每日 EMR 使用量的增加有关(系数=0.61,P 值<.001)。住院医师资历(系数=-1.2,P 值<.001)和远程访问的增加(系数=-0.44,P 值<.001)与每日 EMR 使用量的减少有关。在研究期间,与 2015/2016 学年相比,2018/2019 学年的总 EMR 使用量显著减少(平均差值,2.4 小时与 1.78;P 值<.001)。
在对血管外科服务的 EMR 活动日志进行审核时,平均 EMR 时间为每天 1.6 小时,低于调查估计。住院医师资历和远程访问利用率与 EMR 时间的减少有关,独立于患者普查。尽管通过移动设备和个人计算机增加 EMR 可访问性被假设为导致工作与生活失衡的原因,但我们的研究表明,通过为数据审查提供便捷访问,可能会节省时间,这构成了住院医师 EMR 活动的主要部分。需要在其他机构和专业进行进一步的研究,以进行外部验证,并探讨对住院医师健康倡议的影响。