Froschauer Stefan M, Holzbauer Matthias, Kwasny Oskar, Kastner Philipp, Schnelzer Richard F, Hopfner Meike, Duscher Dominik
Department for Trauma Surgery and Sport Traumatology, Johannes Kepler University Linz, Kepler University Hospital GmbH, Linz, Austria.
Medical Faculty, Johannes Kepler University Linz, Linz, Austria.
J Hand Microsurg. 2020 Sep 17;15(1):13-17. doi: 10.1055/s-0040-1716992. eCollection 2023 Feb.
Music is commonly played in operating rooms. Because microsurgery demands utmost concentration and precise motor control, we conducted the present study to investigate a potentially beneficial impact of music on performing a microsurgical anastomosis. We included a novice group (15 inexperienced medical students) and a professional group (15 experienced microsurgeons) in our study. Simple randomization was performed to allocate participants to the music-playing first or music-playing second cohort. Each participant performed two end-to-end anastomoses on a chicken thigh model. Participant demographics, their subjective preference for work environment (music/no music), and time to completion were noted. The performance of the participants was assessed using the Stanford Microsurgery and Resident Training (SMaRT) scale by an independent examiner, and the final anastomoses were evaluated according to the anastomosis lapse index. Listening to music had no significant effect on time to completion, SMaRT scale, and anastomosis lapse index scores in both novice and professional cohorts. However, the subjective preference to work while listening to music correlated with high SMaRT scale scores within the professional cohort ( = 0.044). Playing their preferred music in the operating room improves the performance scores of surgeons, but only if they subjectively appreciate working with background music.
手术室里通常会播放音乐。由于显微手术需要高度集中注意力和精确的运动控制,我们开展了本研究,以调查音乐对进行显微外科吻合术可能产生的有益影响。
我们的研究纳入了一个新手组(15名缺乏经验的医科学生)和一个专业组(15名经验丰富的显微外科医生)。通过简单随机化将参与者分配到先播放音乐组或后播放音乐组。每位参与者在鸡大腿模型上进行两次端到端吻合术。记录参与者的人口统计学信息、他们对工作环境(有音乐/无音乐)的主观偏好以及完成时间。由一名独立考官使用斯坦福显微手术与住院医师培训(SMaRT)量表评估参与者的操作表现,并根据吻合口失误指数对最终的吻合术进行评估。
在新手组和专业组中,听音乐对完成时间、SMaRT量表评分和吻合口失误指数评分均无显著影响。然而,在专业组中,听音乐时工作的主观偏好与较高的SMaRT量表评分相关(P = 0.044)。
在手术室播放他们喜欢的音乐可以提高外科医生的操作评分,但前提是他们主观上喜欢在背景音乐下工作。