Taraschenko Olga, Pavuluri Spriha, Schmidt Cynthia M, Pulluru Yashwanth Reddy, Gupta Navnika
Division of Epilepsy, Department of Neurological Sciences, University of Nebraska Medical Center, Omaha, NE, United States.
Leon S. McGoogan Health Sciences Library, University of Nebraska Medical Center, Omaha, NE, United States.
Front Neurol. 2023 Jan 24;14:1095061. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2023.1095061. eCollection 2023.
Long-term sequelae of the new onset refractory status epilepticus (NORSE) include the development of epilepsy, cognitive deficits, and behavioral disturbances. The prevalence of these complications has been previously highlighted in case reports and case series: however, their full scope has not been comprehensively assessed.
We conducted a systematic review of the literature (PROSPERO ID CRD42022361142) regarding neurological and functional outcomes of NORSE at 30 days or longer following discharge from the hospital. A systematic review protocol was developed using guidance from the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA).
Of the 1,602 records for unique publications, 33 reports on adults and 52 reports on children met our inclusion criteria. They contained the description of 280 adults and 587 children of whom only 75.7 and 85% of patients, respectively had data on long-term follow-up. The mean age of adult and pediatric patients was 34.3 and 7.9 years, respectively; and the longest duration of follow up were 11 and 20 years, respectively. Seizure outcomes received major attention and were highlighted for 93.4 and 96.6% of the adult and pediatric NORSE patients, respectively. Seizures remained medically refractory in 41.1% of adults and 57.7% of children, while seizure freedom was achieved in only 26 and 23.3% of these patients, respectively. The long-term cognitive outcome data was provided for just 10.4% of the adult patients. In contrast, cognitive health data were supplied for 68.9% of the described children of whom 31.9% were moderately or severely disabled. Long-term functional outcomes assessed with various standardized scales were reported in 62.2 and 25.5% of the adults and children, respectively with majority of patients not being able to return to a pre-morbid level of functioning. New onset psychiatric disorders were reported in 3.3% of adults and 11.2% of children recovering from NORSE.
These findings concur with previous observations that the majority of adult and pediatric patients continue to experience recurrent seizures and suffer from refractory epilepsy. Moderate to severe cognitive disability, loss of functional independence, and psychiatric disorders represent a hallmark of chronic NORSE signifying the major public health importance of this disorder.
新发难治性癫痫持续状态(NORSE)的长期后遗症包括癫痫的发展、认知缺陷和行为障碍。这些并发症的患病率在病例报告和病例系列中已有提及:然而,其全貌尚未得到全面评估。
我们对出院30天或更长时间后NORSE的神经和功能结局的文献进行了系统综述(PROSPERO ID CRD42022361142)。使用系统评价和Meta分析的首选报告项目(PRISMA)的指南制定了系统综述方案。
在1602篇独特出版物的记录中,33篇关于成人的报告和52篇关于儿童的报告符合我们的纳入标准。它们包含了280名成人和587名儿童的描述,其中分别只有75.7%和85%的患者有长期随访数据。成人和儿童患者的平均年龄分别为34.3岁和7.9岁;最长随访时间分别为11年和20年。癫痫结局受到了主要关注,分别有93.4%和96.6%的成人和儿童NORSE患者被重点提及。41.1%的成人和57.7%的儿童癫痫仍药物难治,而这些患者中分别只有26%和23.3%实现了无癫痫发作。仅10.4%的成人患者提供了长期认知结局数据。相比之下,68.9%的所述儿童提供了认知健康数据,其中31.9%为中度或重度残疾。分别有62.2%的成人和25.5%的儿童报告了用各种标准化量表评估的长期功能结局,大多数患者无法恢复到病前的功能水平。3.3%的成人和11.2%从NORSE恢复的儿童报告了新发精神障碍。
这些发现与先前的观察结果一致,即大多数成人和儿童患者继续经历癫痫复发并患有难治性癫痫。中度至重度认知残疾、功能独立丧失和精神障碍是慢性NORSE的标志,表明这种疾病对公共卫生具有重大重要性。