Rao R Mayuri, Banga Simran, Devadas Usha, Maruthy Santosh
All India Institute of Speech and Hearing, Mysore, Karnataka, India.
Department of Speech and Hearing, Manipal College of Health Professions, Manipal Academy of Higher Education, Manipal, Karnataka, India.
J Voice. 2025 Jul;39(4):1134.e1-1134.e12. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2023.01.002. Epub 2023 Feb 13.
The present study aimed to determine the interest and knowledge levels of Indian Carnatic classical singers concerning the vocal function and dysfunction.
Cross-sectional survey.
Self-reporting vocal awareness questionnaire for singers comprising 61 items under nine sections developed by Braum-Janzen and Zeine was adopted and validated to the Carnatic music context. The data was gathered using the snowball sampling method. Each participant spent 10-15 minutes to fill the questionnaire. The 100 participants were divided into two groups based on years of individual singing experience, group 1: Singers with less than 10 years, group 2: Singers with greater than 10 years of individual singing experience.
Few singers reported a thorough understanding in all areas except anatomy and physiology of voice production. As indicated by most of the singers, they were very much interested in expanding their knowledge in (1) the anatomy and physiology of the voice, (2) the role of the speech-language pathologist (SLP) and the voice, (3) the care of the voice, (4) optimal use of the speaking voice, and (5) functional vocal disorders. Further, in both the groups, there was a high number of incorrect and don't know responses. Differences in knowledge levels and interest levels between the two groups were non-significant in all areas (P > 0.05).
Overall, the high number of incorrect and don't know responses suggest that many Carnatic singers do not have even basic knowledge of vocal function and dysfunction, and could benefit from education in these areas. Hence, SLPs need to develop education programs for Carnatic singers towards vocal function and dysfunction so that the development of voice problems in Carnatic singers can be prevented.
本研究旨在确定印度卡纳蒂克古典歌手对发声功能和功能障碍的了解程度与兴趣水平。
横断面调查。
采用由布劳姆 - 扬岑和泽内开发的、包含九个部分61个条目的歌手自我报告发声意识问卷,并根据卡纳蒂克音乐背景进行了验证。数据通过滚雪球抽样法收集。每位参与者花费10 - 15分钟填写问卷。100名参与者根据个人歌唱经验的年限分为两组,第1组:歌唱经验少于10年的歌手,第2组:歌唱经验超过10年的歌手。
除了发声的解剖学和生理学外,很少有歌手表示对所有领域都有透彻的了解。正如大多数歌手所表明的,他们非常有兴趣在以下方面扩展知识:(1)声音的解剖学和生理学,(2)言语语言病理学家(SLP)与声音的作用,(3)声音的护理,(4)说话声音的最佳使用,以及(5)功能性发声障碍。此外,在两组中,不正确和不知道答案的数量都很高。两组在所有领域的知识水平和兴趣水平差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05)。
总体而言,大量不正确和不知道答案的情况表明,许多卡纳蒂克歌手甚至对发声功能和功能障碍没有基本知识,可能会从这些领域的教育中受益。因此,言语语言病理学家需要为卡纳蒂克歌手制定关于发声功能和功能障碍的教育计划,以便预防卡纳蒂克歌手发声问题的发生。