Department of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, University Hospital, LMU Munich, Munich, Germany.
Department of Psychiatry, School of Medicine, University of Queensland, Brisbane, Australia.
Schizophr Bull. 2023 Jul 4;49(4):962-972. doi: 10.1093/schbul/sbad030.
There is limited evidence to guide the approaches to clozapine treatment. Accordingly, an international initiative was undertaken with the aim of developing consensus recommendations for the optimization of clozapine monotherapy.
We conducted an online Delphi survey among members of the Treatment Response and Resistance in Psychosis (TRRIP) working group comprising experts from twenty-nine countries. The threshold criterion for a consensus recommendation was ≥ 75% agreement ("agree" and "strongly agree" responses) on a question. Agreement of ≥ 50% but < 75% in a second or third Delphi round was deemed to provide guidance.
Forty-nine (first round), 32 (second round), and 48 (third round) of the 91 current TRRIP members participated. Expert recommendations at ≥ 75% comprised second-line treatment with clozapine in cases of persistent positive symptoms with co-occurring extrapyramidal symptoms, tardive dyskinesia, or suicidality/aggression. There was considerable disagreement on myocarditis screening parameters. The management of somatic and neuropsychiatric adverse drug reactions warrants further research for more evidence-based recommendations. Rechallenge with clozapine was recommended for eosinophilia, sinus tachycardia and fever and guidance (agreement ≥ 50%) was reached for pneumonia and thrombocytopenia.
Given the limited evidence available, this consensus-based series of recommendations and guidance statements supports clinical decision-making to optimize clozapine monotherapy and provides guidance for future research in treatment-resistant schizophrenia.
目前指导氯氮平治疗方法的证据有限。因此,开展了一项国际性倡议,旨在为优化氯氮平单药治疗制定共识建议。
我们对来自 29 个国家的精神分裂症治疗反应和抵抗性(TRRIP)工作组的成员进行了在线 Delphi 调查。一项共识建议的阈值标准为,对某个问题的应答率达到[≥75%](“同意”和“强烈同意”)。第二轮或第三轮 Delphi 调查中,[≥50%但<75%]的应答率被认为提供了指导。
在 91 名当前 TRRIP 成员中,有 49 名(第一轮)、32 名(第二轮)和 48 名(第三轮)参与。在氯氮平治疗持续性阳性症状伴发锥体外系症状、迟发性运动障碍或自杀/攻击的二线治疗中,专家建议应答率达到[≥75%]。心肌炎筛查参数存在很大分歧。躯体和神经精神不良反应的管理需要进一步研究以提供更有证据的建议。对于嗜酸性粒细胞增多症、窦性心动过速和发热,建议重新使用氯氮平,对于肺炎和血小板减少症,也达成了指导(应答率[≥50%])。
鉴于目前可用的证据有限,这些基于共识的一系列建议和指导声明支持优化氯氮平单药治疗的临床决策,并为治疗抵抗性精神分裂症的未来研究提供指导。