Gierut J A, Elbert M, Dinnsen D A
Department of Psychology, Indiana University, Bloomington 47405.
J Speech Hear Res. 1987 Dec;30(4):462-79. doi: 10.1044/jshr.3004.432.
It has been suggested that a child's productive phonological knowledge may be one factor that potentially accounts for individual differences in generalization learning observed among phonologically disordered children (Dinnsen & Elbert, 1984; Elbert, Dinnsen, & Powell, 1984). This paper evaluates the hypothesis that productive phonological knowledge influences generalization. Three related studies involving 6 functionally misarticulating children were conducted. In the first study, a description of each child's phonological system was developed using procedures of standard generative analysis. Based upon these descriptions, each child's productive phonological knowledge of his or her own sound system was determined and then ranked on a continuum ranging from "most" to "least" knowledge relative to the adult target. The second study implemented an experimental treatment program based upon each child's productive phonological knowledge, with treatment sounds selected directly from each child's continuum of knowledge. The third study reassessed each child's productive phonological knowledge following treatment. The results of these three studies indicated that a child's productive phonological knowledge of the sound system influenced the overall amount of generalization learning. However, the extent of generalization learning was associated with the point on the knowledge continuum at which treatment was initiated. These findings are discussed with reference to individual differences in generalization learning.
有人提出,儿童的生成性语音知识可能是导致语音障碍儿童在泛化学习中出现个体差异的一个潜在因素(丁森和埃尔伯特,1984年;埃尔伯特、丁森和鲍威尔,1984年)。本文评估了生成性语音知识影响泛化这一假设。进行了三项相关研究,涉及6名功能性发音错误的儿童。在第一项研究中,使用标准生成分析程序对每个儿童的语音系统进行了描述。基于这些描述,确定了每个儿童对自己语音系统的生成性语音知识,然后相对于成人目标在从“最多”到“最少”知识的连续体上进行排名。第二项研究基于每个儿童的生成性语音知识实施了一个实验性治疗方案,治疗音直接从每个儿童的知识连续体中选择。第三项研究在治疗后重新评估了每个儿童的生成性语音知识。这三项研究的结果表明,儿童对语音系统的生成性语音知识影响了泛化学习的总体量。然而,泛化学习的程度与开始治疗时在知识连续体上的点有关。将结合泛化学习中的个体差异对这些发现进行讨论。