Wigle Jannah M, Paul Stewart, Birn Anne-Emanuelle, Gladstone Brenda, Kalolo Monica, Banda Lumbani, Braitstein Paula
Social and Behavioural Health Sciences, Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
Parent and Child Health Initiative (PACHI), Lilongwe, Malawi.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2022 Nov 23;2(11):e0001297. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0001297. eCollection 2022.
Despite the global prioritization of addressing adolescent girls' and young women's sexual and reproductive health (SRH) and participatory rights, little research has examined their lived experiences in shaping their engagement in SRH decision-making processes in the global South. Further, few studies have explored how structural and societal factors influence their agency and participation. This critical and focused ethnography, informed by postcolonial feminist and difference-centred citizenship theories, conducted in Malawi (2017-2018) elicited perspectives of youth and key informants to help address these knowledge gaps. Our findings show that the effective implementation and uptake of global discourse on participation and gender equity is hindered by inadequate consideration of girls' and young women's local political, cultural and social realities. Many girls and young women demonstrate passion to participate in SRH policymaking as agents of change. However, patriarchal and gerontocratic political and social structures/institutions, and gendered and adultist norms and practices limit their active and meaningful participation in SRH decision-making. In addition, donors' roles in SRH policymaking and their prioritization of the "girl child" highlight an enduring postcolonial power over agenda-setting processes. Understanding young people's experiences of gendered participation and scrutinizing underlying systemic forces are critical steps toward realizing young women's SRH and participatory rights.
尽管全球都将关注少女和年轻女性的性与生殖健康(SRH)及参与权列为优先事项,但很少有研究考察她们在全球南方地区参与SRH决策过程中的生活经历。此外,很少有研究探讨结构和社会因素如何影响她们的能动性和参与度。这项基于后殖民女权主义和以差异为中心的公民理论的批判性聚焦人种志研究于2017年至2018年在马拉维进行,收集了青年和关键信息提供者的观点,以填补这些知识空白。我们的研究结果表明,由于对女孩和年轻女性当地的政治、文化和社会现实考虑不足,全球关于参与和性别平等的话语的有效实施和接受受到阻碍。许多女孩和年轻女性表现出作为变革推动者参与SRH政策制定的热情。然而,父权制和老年统治的政治及社会结构/机构,以及性别化和成人主义的规范与做法限制了她们在SRH决策中的积极和有意义的参与。此外,捐助者在SRH政策制定中的作用及其对“女童”的优先重视凸显了在后殖民时期对议程设定过程的持久权力。了解年轻人在性别化参与方面的经历并审视潜在的系统性力量是实现年轻女性的SRH和参与权的关键步骤。