Oliver Daniel, Fairlie Robert, Millhauser Glenn, Roland Randa
Tulane University, New Orleans, USA.
University of California, Santa Cruz, USA.
Econ Educ Rev. 2021 Aug;83. doi: 10.1016/j.econedurev.2021.102125. Epub 2021 May 12.
Graduate student teaching assistants from underrepresented groups may provide salient role models and enhanced instruction to minority students in STEM fields. We explore minority student-TA interactions in an important course in the sciences and STEM - introductory chemistry labs - at a large public university. The uncommon assignment method of students to TA instructors in these chemistry labs overcomes selection problems, and the small and active learning classroom setting with required attendance provides frequent interactions with the TA. We find evidence that underrepresented minority students are less likely to drop courses and are more likely to pass courses when assigned to minority TAs, but we do not find evidence of effects for grades and medium-term outcomes. The effects for the first-order outcomes are large with a decrease in the drop rate by 5.5 percentage points on a base of 6 percent, and an increase in the pass rate of 4.8 percentage points on a base of 93.6 percent. The findings are similar when we focus on Latinx student - Latinx TA interactions. The findings are robust to first-time vs. multiple enrollments in labs, specifications with different levels of fixed effects, limited choice of TA race, limited information of TAs, and low registration priority students. The findings have implications for debates over increasing diversity among PhD students in STEM fields because of spillovers to minority undergraduates.
来自代表性不足群体的研究生助教可能会为理工科领域的少数族裔学生提供显著的榜样作用,并增强教学效果。我们在一所大型公立大学的一门重要科学课程以及理工科入门化学实验室中,探讨少数族裔学生与助教之间的互动。在这些化学实验室中,学生被分配给助教的不寻常方式克服了选拔问题,而且小班化且要求出勤的主动学习课堂环境使得学生与助教之间有频繁的互动。我们发现有证据表明,当被分配给少数族裔助教时,代表性不足的少数族裔学生退课的可能性较小,通过课程的可能性较大,但我们没有发现对成绩和中期结果有影响的证据。一阶结果的影响很大,退课率在6%的基础上下降了5.5个百分点,通过率在93.6%的基础上提高了4.8个百分点。当我们关注拉丁裔学生与拉丁裔助教之间的互动时,研究结果相似。这些结果对于首次参加实验室课程与多次参加实验室课程的情况、具有不同固定效应水平的设定、助教种族选择有限、助教信息有限以及注册优先级较低的学生来说都是稳健的。由于对少数族裔本科生有溢出效应,这些研究结果对理工科领域博士生增加多样性的争论具有启示意义。