Tonetti Maurizio S, Heitz-Mayfield Lisa, Papapanou Panos N, Sanz Mariano
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Implantology, National Clinical Research Center of Stomatology, Shanghai PerioImplant Innovation Center, Ninth People's Hospital, Shanghai Jiao Tong University School of Medicine, Shanghai, China.
European Research Group on Periodontology, Bern, Switzerland.
J Periodontol. 2023 Apr 10. doi: 10.1002/JPER.23-0203.
Consensus on a valid and comprehensive set of outcomes to capture the full benefits and harms of implant dentistry interventions is key for progress towards better clinical guidelines and policy. In this field, outcome research remains fragmented and uses too many different outcomes. Accordingly, such efforts are still unable to cover the full breadth necessary to properly evaluate benefits, harms, and costs. Best practice examples from medicine have inspired the Implant Dentistry Core Outcome Set and Measurements (ID-COSM) initiative that identified four core outcome domain areas (pathophysiology, implant/prosthesis lifespan, life impact, and access to care) and five essential outcomes mandatory for all trials, plus six others that are mandatory in specific circumstances. The innovative multistep approach has combined input from scientific evidence, patients from multiple countries, methodologists, and industry representatives. It is an important step. The ID-COSM consensus aspires to contribute to better adoption of relevant and valid outcomes in trials and enable combining their results in high-quality meta-analyses to support better informed care and policy.
就一套有效且全面的结果达成共识,以充分体现种植义齿干预措施的全部益处和危害,这是制定更好的临床指南和政策的关键。在该领域,结果研究仍然零散,使用的结果种类过多。因此,这些努力仍无法涵盖正确评估益处、危害和成本所需的全部范围。医学领域的最佳实践范例激发了种植义齿核心结果集与测量(ID - COSM)倡议,该倡议确定了四个核心结果领域(病理生理学、种植体/修复体寿命、生活影响和获得医疗服务)以及所有试验必须具备的五个基本结果,另外还有在特定情况下必须具备的六个结果。这种创新的多步骤方法结合了科学证据、来自多个国家的患者、方法学家和行业代表的意见。这是重要的一步。ID - COSM共识旨在促进在试验中更好地采用相关且有效的结果,并能够在高质量的荟萃分析中合并这些结果,以支持更明智的医疗护理和政策制定。