Department of Medicine, Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Department of Laboratory Medicine and Pathobiology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
PLoS One. 2023 Apr 18;18(4):e0284425. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0284425. eCollection 2023.
Despite the fact that direct oral anticoagulants (DOACs) are favoured over warfarin for stroke prevention in patients with non-valvular atrial fibrillation (NVAF), physicians need to maintain competence in using and monitoring warfarin since many patients have contraindications or other barriers to using DOACs. Unlike DOACs, warfarin therapy requires regular blood testing to ensure that it is within a target range to ensure efficacy and safety. There is limited real-world data on the adequacy of warfarin control and the cost and burden of monitoring warfarin therapy in Canadian NVAF patients.
In a large cohort of Canadian patients with NVAF on warfarin we assessed time in therapeutic range (TTR), determinants of TTR, process of care, direct costs, health related quality of life and loss of work time and productivity related to warfarin therapy.
Five hundred and fifty one patients with NVAF, either newly initiated or stable on warfarin were prospectively enrolled across 9 Canadian provinces from primary care practices and anticoagulant clinics. Participating physicians provided baseline demographic and medical information. Patients completed diaries for 48 weeks, capturing information about International Normalized Ratio (INR) test results, test locations, process of INR monitoring, direct costs of travel, health-related quality of life and work productivity measures. TTR was estimated using linear interpolation of INR results and linear regression used to investigate associations between TTR and factors (defined a priori).
Four hundred and eighty (87.1%) patients had complete follow-up with an overall TTR of 74.4% based on 7,175 physician-reported INR values from 501 patients. 88% of this cohort were monitored through routine medical care (RMC). The average number of INRs per patient during the 48-week period was 14.1 (standard deviation (SD) = 8.3) tests with a mean duration of 23.8 (SD = 11.1) days between tests. We did not find a relationship between TTR and age, sex, presence of major comorbidities, patient's province of residence or rural vs. urban residence. 12% of patients monitored through anticoagulant clinics had significantly better TTR than patients monitored through RMC (82% vs. 74%; 95% confidence interval: -13.8, -1.2; p = 0.02). Health related quality of life utility values were high and remained consistent throughout the study. The majority of patients reported no impact on either work productivity or impairment of regular activities due to being on long-term warfarin treatment.
We showed excellent overall TTR in an observed Canadian cohort, with monitoring through a dedicated anticoagulant clinic being associated with a statistically and clinically significant improvement in TTR. The burden of warfarin therapy on patients' health related quality of life or daily work and activities was low.
尽管直接口服抗凝剂(DOAC)在预防非瓣膜性心房颤动(NVAF)患者中风方面优于华法林,但由于许多患者存在 DOAC 的禁忌症或其他障碍,医生仍需保持使用和监测华法林的能力。与 DOAC 不同,华法林治疗需要定期进行血液检查,以确保其处于目标范围内,以确保疗效和安全性。加拿大 NVAF 患者华法林控制的充分性、监测华法林治疗的成本和负担的真实世界数据有限。
在接受华法林治疗的 NVAF 患者的大型队列中,我们评估了治疗范围内时间(TTR)、TTR 的决定因素、治疗过程、直接成本、健康相关生活质量以及与华法林治疗相关的工作时间和生产力损失。
551 名 NVAF 患者,新开始或稳定接受华法林治疗,来自加拿大 9 个省的初级保健诊所和抗凝诊所进行前瞻性入组。参与的医生提供了基线人口统计学和医学信息。患者完成了 48 周的日记,记录了 INR 测试结果、测试地点、INR 监测过程、旅行的直接费用、健康相关生活质量和工作生产力测量的信息。TTR 通过 INR 结果的线性插值进行估计,并使用线性回归调查 TTR 与因素(预先定义)之间的关联。
480 名(87.1%)患者完成了完整的随访,基于 501 名患者的 7175 份医生报告的 INR 值,总体 TTR 为 74.4%。该队列的 88%通过常规医疗护理(RMC)进行监测。在 48 周期间,每名患者的 INR 平均次数为 14.1(标准差(SD)=8.3)次,两次测试之间的平均时间为 23.8(SD=11.1)天。我们没有发现 TTR 与年龄、性别、主要合并症的存在、患者所在省份或农村与城市居住之间的关系。通过抗凝诊所监测的 12%的患者 TTR 明显优于通过 RMC 监测的患者(82% vs. 74%;95%置信区间:-13.8,-1.2;p=0.02)。健康相关生活质量效用值较高,并且在整个研究过程中保持一致。大多数患者报告由于长期服用华法林治疗,对工作生产力或日常活动的正常进行没有影响。
我们在观察到的加拿大队列中显示了出色的总体 TTR,通过专门的抗凝诊所进行监测与 TTR 的统计学和临床显著改善相关。华法林治疗对患者健康相关生活质量或日常工作和活动的负担较低。