Cognitive Neuroscience Department, International School for Advanced Studies, 34136 Trieste, Italy
Cognitive Neuroscience Department, International School for Advanced Studies, 34136 Trieste, Italy.
J Neurosci. 2023 May 24;43(21):3860-3875. doi: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.1451-22.2023. Epub 2023 Apr 21.
What we see in the present is affected by what we saw in the recent past. Serial dependence, a bias making a current stimulus appear more similar to a previous one, has been indeed shown to be ubiquitous in vision. At the neural level, serial dependence is accompanied by a signature of stimulus history (i.e., past stimulus information) emerging from early visual-evoked activity. However, whether this neural signature effectively reflects the behavioral bias is unclear. Here we address this question by assessing the neural (electrophysiological) and behavioral signature of stimulus history in human subjects (both male and female), in the context of numerosity, duration, and size perception. First, our results show that while the behavioral effect is task-dependent, its neural signature also reflects task-irrelevant dimensions of a past stimulus, suggesting a partial dissociation between the mechanisms mediating the encoding of stimulus history and the behavioral bias itself. Second, we show that performing a task is not a necessary condition to observe the neural signature of stimulus history, but that in the presence of an active task such a signature is significantly amplified. Finally, and more importantly, we show that the pattern of brain activity in a relatively early latency window (starting at ∼35-65 ms after stimulus onset) significantly predicts the behavioral effect. Overall, our results thus demonstrate that the encoding of past stimulus information in neural signals does indeed reflect serial dependence, and that serial dependence occurs at a relatively early level of visual processing. What we perceive is determined not only by the information reaching our sensory organs, but also by the context in which the information is embedded. What we saw in the recent past (perceptual history) can indeed modulate the perception of a current stimulus in an attractive way, a bias that is ubiquitous in vision. Here we show that this bias can be predicted by the pattern of brain activity reflecting the encoding of past stimulus information, very early after the onset of a stimulus. This in turn suggests that the integration of past and present sensory information mediating the attractive bias occurs early in the visual processing stream, and likely involves early visual cortices.
我们现在所看到的受到近期所见的影响。序列依赖,即当前刺激看起来与前一个刺激更相似的偏差,已被证明在视觉中普遍存在。在神经水平上,序列依赖伴随着来自早期视觉诱发活动的刺激历史(即过去刺激信息)的特征出现。然而,这种神经特征是否能有效地反映行为偏差尚不清楚。在这里,我们通过评估人类受试者(男性和女性)在数量、持续时间和大小感知方面的刺激历史的神经(电生理)和行为特征来解决这个问题。首先,我们的结果表明,虽然行为效应取决于任务,但它的神经特征也反映了过去刺激的任务无关维度,这表明介导刺激历史编码的机制与行为偏差本身之间存在部分分离。其次,我们表明,执行任务不是观察刺激历史的神经特征的必要条件,但在存在主动任务的情况下,这种特征会显著放大。最后,更重要的是,我们表明,在相对较早的潜伏期窗口(刺激开始后约 35-65 毫秒开始)中的脑活动模式显著预测了行为效应。总的来说,我们的结果表明,过去刺激信息在神经信号中的编码确实反映了序列依赖,并且序列依赖发生在相对较早的视觉处理水平。我们所感知的不仅取决于到达我们感觉器官的信息,还取决于信息所处的上下文。我们最近看到的(感知历史)确实可以以吸引人的方式调节当前刺激的感知,这种偏差在视觉中普遍存在。在这里,我们表明,这种偏差可以通过反映过去刺激信息编码的脑活动模式来预测,这发生在刺激开始后非常早的阶段。这反过来表明,介导吸引力偏差的过去和现在感觉信息的整合发生在视觉处理流的早期,并且可能涉及早期的视觉皮层。