School of Population Health, Faculty of Health Sciences, Curtin University, Bentley, WA, Australia.
Telethon Kids Institute, Nedlands, WA, Australia.
Int J Epidemiol. 2023 Aug 2;52(4):1124-1136. doi: 10.1093/ije/dyad052.
Reliable and detailed data on the prevalence of tuberculosis (TB) with sub-national estimates are scarce in Ethiopia. We address this knowledge gap by spatially predicting the national, sub-national and local prevalence of TB, and identifying drivers of TB prevalence across the country.
TB prevalence data were obtained from the Ethiopia national TB prevalence survey and from a comprehensive review of published reports. Geospatial covariates were obtained from publicly available sources. A random effects meta-analysis was used to estimate a pooled prevalence of TB at the national level, and model-based geostatistics were used to estimate the spatial variation of TB prevalence at sub-national and local levels. Within the MBG Plugin Framework, a logistic regression model was fitted to TB prevalence data using both fixed covariate effects and spatial random effects to identify drivers of TB and to predict the prevalence of TB.
The overall pooled prevalence of TB in Ethiopia was 0.19% [95% confidence intervals (CI): 0.12%-0.28%]. There was a high degree of heterogeneity in the prevalence of TB (I2 96.4%, P <0.001), which varied by geographical locations, data collection periods and diagnostic methods. The highest prevalence of TB was observed in Dire Dawa (0.96%), Gambela (0.88%), Somali (0.42%), Addis Ababa (0.28%) and Afar (0.24%) regions. Nationally, there was a decline in TB prevalence from 0.18% in 2001 to 0.04% in 2009. However, prevalence increased back to 0.29% in 2014. Substantial spatial variation of TB prevalence was observed at a regional level, with a higher prevalence observed in the border regions, and at a local level within regions. The spatial distribution of TB prevalence was positively associated with population density.
The results of this study showed that TB prevalence varied substantially at sub-national and local levels in Ethiopia. Spatial patterns were associated with population density. These results suggest that targeted interventions in high-risk areas may reduce the burden of TB in Ethiopia and additional data collection would be required to make further inferences on TB prevalence in areas that lack data.
在埃塞俄比亚,可靠且详细的国家级结核病(TB)流行数据和省级估计数据都很缺乏。我们通过对全国范围内的结核病流行情况进行空间预测,并确定影响结核病流行的驱动因素,来填补这一知识空白。
结核病流行数据来自埃塞俄比亚全国结核病流行调查和对已发表报告的全面审查。地理空间协变量来自公开来源。采用随机效应荟萃分析估计全国范围内的结核病总流行率,采用基于模型的地质统计学估计省级和县级结核病流行率的空间变化。在 MBG 插件框架内,使用固定协变量效应和空间随机效应,对结核病流行数据拟合逻辑回归模型,以确定结核病的驱动因素并预测结核病的流行率。
埃塞俄比亚全国结核病总流行率为 0.19%[95%置信区间(CI):0.12%-0.28%]。结核病的流行率存在高度异质性(I2 96.4%,P<0.001),这取决于地理位置、数据收集时期和诊断方法。结核病的最高流行率出现在德雷达瓦(0.96%)、甘贝拉(0.88%)、索马里(0.42%)、亚的斯亚贝巴(0.28%)和阿法尔(0.24%)地区。全国范围内,结核病流行率从 2001 年的 0.18%下降到 2009 年的 0.04%。然而,2014 年又回升至 0.29%。在区域一级观察到结核病流行率存在显著的空间变化,在边境地区和区域内的地方一级,流行率更高。结核病流行率的空间分布与人口密度呈正相关。
本研究结果表明,埃塞俄比亚的结核病流行率在省级和县级之间存在很大差异。空间模式与人口密度有关。这些结果表明,在高风险地区采取有针对性的干预措施可能会降低埃塞俄比亚的结核病负担,并且需要进一步收集数据,以对缺乏数据的地区的结核病流行率做出进一步推断。