Hayden Emily M, Borczuk Pierre, Dutta Sayon, Filbin Michael R, Liu Shan W, White Benjamin A, Kugener Eleonore, Parry Blair A, Horick Nora, Zachrison Kori S
Department of Emergency Medicine Massachusetts General Hospital Boston Massachusetts USA.
Biostatistics Center Massachusetts General Hospital Boston Massachusetts USA.
J Am Coll Emerg Physicians Open. 2023 May 12;4(3):e12963. doi: 10.1002/emp2.12963. eCollection 2023 Jun.
There is limited evidence on the reliability of video-based physical examinations. We aimed to evaluate the safety of a remote physician-directed abdominal examination using tablet-based video.
This was a prospective observational pilot study of patients >19 years old presenting with abdominal pain to an academic emergency department July 9, 2021-December 21, 2021. In addition to usual care, patients had a tablet video-based telehealth history and examination by an emergency physician who was otherwise not involved in the visit. Both telehealth and in-person clinicians were asked about the patient's need for abdominal imaging (yes/no). Thirty-day chart review searched for subsequent ED visits, hospitalizations, and procedures. Our primary outcome was agreement between telehealth and in-person clinicians on imaging need. Our secondary outcome was potentially missed imaging by the telehealth physicians leading to morbidity or mortality. We used descriptive and bivariate analyses to examine characteristics associated with disagreement on imaging needs.
Fifty-six patients were enrolled; the median age was 43 years (interquartile range: 27-59), 31 (55%) were female. The telehealth and in-person clinicians agreed on the need for imaging in 42 (75%) of the patients (95% confidence interval [CI]: 62%-86%), with moderate agreement with Cohen's kappa ((k = 0.41, 95% CI: 0.15-0.67). For study patients who had a procedure within 24 hours of ED arrival (n = 3, 5.4%, 95% CI: 1.1%-14.9%) or within 30 days (n = 7, 12.5%, 95% CI: 5.2%-24.1%), neither telehealth physicians nor in-person clinicians missed timely imaging.
In this pilot study, telehealth physicians and in-person clinicians agreed on the need for imaging for the majority of patients with abdominal pain. Importantly, telehealth physicians did not miss the identification of imaging needs for patients requiring urgent or emergent surgery.
关于基于视频的体格检查的可靠性证据有限。我们旨在评估使用平板电脑视频进行远程医生指导的腹部检查的安全性。
这是一项前瞻性观察性试点研究,研究对象为2021年7月9日至2021年12月21日到一所学术急诊科就诊的19岁以上腹痛患者。除常规护理外,患者通过平板电脑视频进行远程医疗病史采集,并由一名未参与此次就诊的急诊科医生进行检查。远程医疗和现场临床医生均被询问患者是否需要进行腹部成像检查(是/否)。对30天的病历进行回顾,以查找随后的急诊科复诊、住院情况和诊疗操作。我们的主要结局是远程医疗和现场临床医生在成像需求方面的一致性。我们的次要结局是远程医疗医生可能遗漏成像检查,从而导致发病或死亡。我们使用描述性和双变量分析来检查与成像需求不一致相关的特征。
共纳入56例患者;中位年龄为43岁(四分位间距:27 - 59岁),31例(55%)为女性。远程医疗和现场临床医生在42例(75%)患者的成像需求上达成一致(95%置信区间[CI]:62% - 86%),Cohen's kappa系数显示一致性中等(κ = 0.41,95% CI:0.15 - 0.67)。对于在急诊科就诊后24小时内(n = 3,5.4%,95% CI:1.1% - 14.9%)或30天内(n = 7,12.5%,95% CI:5.2% - 24.1%)接受诊疗操作的研究患者,远程医疗医生和现场临床医生均未遗漏及时成像检查。
在这项试点研究中,远程医疗医生和现场临床医生在大多数腹痛患者的成像需求上达成一致。重要的是,远程医疗医生没有遗漏对需要紧急手术患者的成像需求识别。