University of Bath, Department of Chemistry, Bath BA2 7AY, United Kingdom.
Stellenbosch University, Department of Process Engineering, Stellenbosch, South Africa.
Water Res. 2023 Jul 15;240:120110. doi: 10.1016/j.watres.2023.120110. Epub 2023 May 21.
There has been a significant increase in antimicrobial agents (AAs) usage, globally - however the relative consumption is unevenly distributed between nations. Inappropriate use of antibiotics can harbour inherent antimicrobial resistance (AMR); therefore, it is important to understand and monitor community-wide prescribing and consumption behaviours throughout different communities around the world. Wastewater-Based Epidemiology (WBE) is a novel tool enabling low cost and large scale studies focussed on AA usage patterns. The back-calculation of community antimicrobial intake was performed from quantities measured in municipal wastewater and informal settlement discharge in the city of Stellenbosch, utilising WBE. Seventeen antimicrobials, and their human metabolites, were evaluated, in concordance with prescription records corresponding to the catchment region. The proportional excretion, biological/chemical stability, and method recovery of each analyte were all crucial factors in the efficacy of the calculation. Mass per day measurements were normalised to the catchment area via population estimates. Municipal wastewater treatment plant population estimates were used to normalise the wastewater samples and prescription data (mg/day/1000 inhabitants). Population estimates for the informal settlements were less accurate due to a lack of reliable sources that were relevant to the sampling time period. Both mass loads and normalised loads suggested higher than average usage throughout the settlements, relative to municipal wastewater. This was seen most prominently in emtricitabine and lamivudine; but also, sulfamethoxazole, trimethoprim, sulfadiazine, clindamycin, ciprofloxacin, ofloxacin, and doxycycline. Urban water fingerprinting (UWF) data triangulation with prescription datasets showed good correlations for several antimicrobial agents (AAs) (e.g., clindamycin, clarithromycin, ofloxacin, and doxycycline). It also revealed discrepancies in usage for some compounds (e.g., tetracycline and sulfapyridine). This might be linked with a lack of pharma compliance in prescription datasets; erroneous association of prescription boundaries with the sewerage catchment; and/or uncertainties within the sewerage catchment (e.g., population estimations). The UWF tool provided a comprehensive overview of multiclass AAs usage, both prescription and over-the counter. For example, tetracycline was not reported in available prescription statistics, but was detected at an average of 18.4 mg/day/1000inh; and no antiviral prescriptions were obtained, but emtricitabine and lamivudine were quantified at 2415.4 and 144.4 mg/day/1000inh, respectively. A lack of clarity regarding prescriptions and a lack of inclusion of several critical (often over-the-counter) medications in public health databases makes WBE a useful and comprehensive epidemiology tool for tracking pharma usage within a catchment.
全球范围内,抗生素(Antimicrobial agents,AAs)的使用量显著增加——然而,各国之间的使用量分布不均。抗生素的不合理使用会导致固有抗菌耐药性(Antimicrobial resistance,AMR);因此,了解和监测全球不同社区的社区范围内处方和消费行为非常重要。基于污水的流行病学(Wastewater-Based Epidemiology,WBE)是一种新工具,可用于低成本、大规模研究抗生素使用模式。通过利用 WBE,从城市污水和斯泰伦博斯市非正规住区排放中测量的数量对社区的抗生素摄入量进行了反推。评估了 17 种抗生素及其人类代谢物,并与相应集水区的处方记录相吻合。每个分析物的比例排泄、生物/化学稳定性和方法回收率都是计算功效的关键因素。通过人口估计将每天的质量测量值归一化为集水区。使用城市污水处理厂的人口估计值对污水样本和处方数据(mg/天/1000 居民)进行归一化。由于缺乏与采样时间段相关的可靠来源,非正规住区的人口估计值不太准确。相对于城市污水,非正规住区的污水样本和处方数据都显示出较高的药物使用量,这一点在恩曲他滨和拉米夫定最为明显;但也有磺胺甲噁唑、甲氧苄啶、磺胺嘧啶、克林霉素、环丙沙星、氧氟沙星和强力霉素。城市水指纹(Urban water fingerprinting,UWF)数据与处方数据集的三角剖分显示,几种抗生素(如克林霉素、克拉霉素、环丙沙星和强力霉素)的相关性较好。它还揭示了一些化合物(如四环素和磺胺吡啶)的使用差异。这可能与处方数据集中缺乏药物合规性、处方边界与下水道集水区的错误关联以及/或下水道集水区内的不确定性(例如,人口估计)有关。UWF 工具全面概述了多类抗生素(包括处方药和非处方药)的使用情况。例如,四环素未在现有处方统计数据中报告,但平均每天检测到 18.4mg/天/1000inh;并且没有获得抗病毒处方,但每天检测到恩曲他滨和拉米夫定分别为 2415.4 和 144.4mg/天/1000inh。由于处方不清楚以及公共卫生数据库中未包含几种关键(通常是非处方药)药物,WBE 成为一种有用且全面的流行病学工具,可用于跟踪集水区内的药物使用情况。