Yüksel Mustafa, Sarlik Esra, Çiprut Ayça
Ankara Medipol University School of Health Sciences, Department of Speech and Language Therapy, Ankara, Turkey.
Marmara University Institute of Health Sciences, Audiology and Speech Disorders Program, Istanbul, Turkey.
Ear Hear. 2023;44(6):1451-1463. doi: 10.1097/AUD.0000000000001388. Epub 2023 Jun 7.
Music is a multidimensional phenomenon and is classified by its arousal properties, emotional quality, and structural characteristics. Although structural features of music (i.e., pitch, timbre, and tempo) and music emotion recognition in cochlear implant (CI) recipients are popular research topics, music-evoked emotions, and related psychological mechanisms that reflect both the individual and social context of music are largely ignored. Understanding the music-evoked emotions (the "what") and related mechanisms (the "why") can help professionals and CI recipients better comprehend the impact of music on CI recipients' daily lives. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to evaluate these aspects in CI recipients and compare their findings to those of normal hearing (NH) controls.
This study included 50 CI recipients with diverse auditory experiences who were prelingually deafened (deafened at or before 6 years of age)-early implanted (N = 21), prelingually deafened-late implanted (implanted at or after 12 years of age-N = 13), and postlingually deafened (N = 16) as well as 50 age-matched NH controls. All participants completed the same survey, which included 28 emotions and 10 mechanisms (Brainstem reflex, Rhythmic entrainment, Evaluative Conditioning, Contagion, Visual imagery, Episodic memory, Musical expectancy, Aesthetic judgment, Cognitive appraisal, and Lyrics). Data were presented in detail for CI groups and compared between CI groups and between CI and NH groups.
The principal component analysis showed five emotion factors that are explained by 63.4% of the total variance, including anxiety and anger, happiness and pride, sadness and pain, sympathy and tenderness, and serenity and satisfaction in the CI group. Positive emotions such as happiness, tranquility, love, joy, and trust ranked as most often experienced in all groups, whereas negative and complex emotions such as guilt, fear, anger, and anxiety ranked lowest. The CI group ranked lyrics and rhythmic entrainment highest in the emotion mechanism, and there was a statistically significant group difference in the episodic memory mechanism, in which the prelingually deafened, early implanted group scored the lowest.
Our findings indicate that music can evoke similar emotions in CI recipients with diverse auditory experiences as it does in NH individuals. However, prelingually deafened and early implanted individuals lack autobiographical memories associated with music, which affects the feelings evoked by music. In addition, the preference for rhythmic entrainment and lyrics as mechanisms of music-elicited emotions suggests that rehabilitation programs should pay particular attention to these cues.
音乐是一种多维现象,可根据其唤起特性、情感特质和结构特征进行分类。尽管音乐的结构特征(即音高、音色和节奏)以及人工耳蜗(CI)植入者的音乐情感识别是热门研究课题,但音乐引发的情感以及反映音乐个人和社会背景的相关心理机制在很大程度上被忽视了。了解音乐引发的情感(“是什么”)和相关机制(“为什么”)有助于专业人员和CI植入者更好地理解音乐对CI植入者日常生活的影响。因此,本研究的目的是评估CI植入者的这些方面,并将其结果与正常听力(NH)对照组进行比较。
本研究纳入了50名有不同听觉经历的CI植入者,他们分别是语前聋(6岁及以前失聪)-早期植入(N = 21)、语前聋-晚期植入(12岁及以后植入-N = 13)、语后聋(N = 16),以及50名年龄匹配的NH对照组。所有参与者都完成了相同的调查问卷,其中包括28种情感和10种机制(脑干反射、节奏同步、评价性条件反射、感染、视觉意象、情景记忆、音乐期待、审美判断、认知评价和歌词)。详细呈现了CI组的数据,并在CI组之间以及CI组与NH组之间进行了比较。
主成分分析显示了五个情感因素,占总方差的63.4%,CI组中的这些因素包括焦虑和愤怒、幸福和自豪、悲伤和痛苦、同情和温柔、平静和满足。幸福、安宁、爱、喜悦和信任等积极情绪在所有组中被列为最常体验到的情绪,而内疚、恐惧、愤怒和焦虑等消极和复杂情绪则排名最低。CI组在情感机制中将歌词和节奏同步排在最高位,并且在情景记忆机制方面存在统计学上的显著组间差异,其中语前聋、早期植入组得分最低。
我们的研究结果表明,音乐在有不同听觉经历的CI植入者中能唤起与NH个体类似的情感。然而,语前聋且早期植入的个体缺乏与音乐相关的自传体记忆,这会影响音乐唤起的感受。此外,对节奏同步和歌词作为音乐引发情感机制的偏好表明,康复计划应特别关注这些线索。