Du Meng, Hu Yueyu, Zhu Deyuan, Cao Wei, Li Peng, Qi Dayong, Wu Chao, He Juanling, Ye Shifei, Li Suya, Fang Yibin
Department of Neurovascular Disease, Shanghai Fourth People's Hospital, School of Medicine, Tongji University, Shanghai, China.
Angiology. 2024 Jul;75(6):517-526. doi: 10.1177/00033197231183231. Epub 2023 Jun 11.
There is an increasing number of studies on the transradial approach (TRA) for carotid artery stenting. We aimed to summarize the published data on TRA vs the transfemoral approach (TFA). We searched Science Direct, Embase, PubMed, and Web of Science databases for the relevant literature. Primary outcomes included surgical success and cardiovascular and cerebrovascular complication rates; secondary outcomes included the rates of vascular access-related and other complications. We also compared the crossover rate, success rate, and complications between TRA and TFA carotid stenting. This is the first such meta-analysis regarding TRA and TFA. Twenty studies on TRA carotid stenting were included (n = 1300). Among 19 studies, the success rate of TRA carotid stenting was .951 (95% confidence interval [CI]: .926-.975); death rate was .022 (.011-.032); stroke rate was .005 (.001-.008); radial artery occlusion rate was .008 (.003-.013); and forearm hematoma rate was .003 (-.000 to .006). Among 4 studies comparing TRA and TFA, the success rate was lower (odds ratio: .02; 95% CI: .00-.23) and crossover rate was higher (odds ratio: 40.16; 95% CI: 4.41-365.73) with TRA. Thus, transradial neuro-interventional surgery has a lower success rate than TFA.
关于经桡动脉途径(TRA)进行颈动脉支架置入术的研究越来越多。我们旨在总结已发表的关于TRA与经股动脉途径(TFA)的数据。我们在科学Direct、Embase、PubMed和Web of Science数据库中搜索相关文献。主要结局包括手术成功率以及心血管和脑血管并发症发生率;次要结局包括血管入路相关和其他并发症的发生率。我们还比较了TRA和TFA颈动脉支架置入术之间的交叉率、成功率和并发症。这是关于TRA和TFA的首个此类荟萃分析。纳入了20项关于TRA颈动脉支架置入术的研究(n = 1300)。在19项研究中,TRA颈动脉支架置入术的成功率为0.951(95%置信区间[CI]:0.926 - 0.975);死亡率为0.022(0.011 - 0.032);卒中发生率为0.005(0.001 - 0.008);桡动脉闭塞率为[0.008(0.003 - 0.013)];前臂血肿发生率为0.003(-0.000至0.006)。在4项比较TRA和TFA的研究中,TRA的成功率较低(优势比:0.02;95% CI:0.00 - 0.23)且交叉率较高(优势比:40.16;95% CI:4.41 - 365.73)。因此,经桡动脉神经介入手术的成功率低于TFA。 (注:原文中“forearm hematoma rate was.003 (-.000 to.006).”括号内数据表述不太规范,翻译时保留原样)