Liao Shudi, Zeng Jianpeng, Wei Lihua
School of Business, Hubei University, Wuhan, People's Republic of China.
School of Business, Zhengzhou University of Aeronautics, Zhengzhou, People's Republic of China.
Psychol Res Behav Manag. 2023 Jun 15;16:2225-2240. doi: 10.2147/PRBM.S413872. eCollection 2023.
Although plenty of studies have examined the antecedents of organizational citizenship behavior, empirical studies exploring the role of individual narcissism in relation to college students' organizational citizenship behavior are relatively scarce. Drawing on the dual theory of narcissism and the conservation of resources theory, this study aimed to explore the relationship between narcissistic duality traits (narcissistic admiration and narcissistic rivalry) and organizational citizenship behavior of college students, and to further examine the mediating role of impression management motivation (assertive impression management motivation and defensive impression management motivation) and the moderating roles of teamwork, interpersonal relationships, and optimism.
We used the questionnaire method with a sample of undergraduate and graduate students from several universities in Hubei, China. The data sample for analysis consists of 583 college students.
(1) Narcissistic admiration had a significant and positive effect on college students' organizational citizenship behavior, while the effect of narcissistic rivalry was significant and negative; (2) assertive impression management motivation mediated the relationship between narcissistic admiration and college student's organizational citizenship behavior, and defensive impression management motivation mediated the relationship between narcissistic rivalry and college student' s organizational citizenship behavior; and (3) teamwork, interpersonal relationships, and optimism positively moderated the relationship between narcissistic admiration and assertive impression management motivation, and these variables positively moderated the indirect effects of assertive narcissism on college student's organizational citizenship behavior through assertive impression management motivation.
We found that college students with narcissistic admiration engaged in more organizational citizenship behaviors than those with narcissistic rivalry. In addition, narcissistic admiration had a positive effect on organizational citizenship behavior through assertive impression management motivation, and narcissistic rivalry had a negative effect on organizational citizenship behavior through defensive impression management motivation. Finally, teamwork, interpersonal relationships, and optimism significantly and positively mediated the relationship between narcissistic admiration and assertive impression management motivation, and the indirect effect of narcissistic admiration on organizational citizenship behavior through assertive impression management motivation. However, the direct effects of teamwork, interpersonal relationships, and optimism on the relationship between narcissistic rivalry and defensive impression management motivation, and the indirect effect of narcissistic rivalry on organizational citizenship behavior through defensive impression management motivation were not significant.
尽管大量研究考察了组织公民行为的前因,但探索个体自恋与大学生组织公民行为关系的实证研究相对较少。本研究基于自恋的二元理论和资源守恒理论,旨在探讨自恋二元特质(自恋钦佩和自恋竞争)与大学生组织公民行为之间的关系,并进一步考察印象管理动机(主动印象管理动机和防御性印象管理动机)的中介作用以及团队合作、人际关系和乐观主义的调节作用。
我们采用问卷调查法,以中国湖北省几所大学的本科生和研究生为样本。用于分析的数据样本包括583名大学生。
(1)自恋钦佩对大学生的组织公民行为有显著正向影响,而自恋竞争的影响则显著为负;(2)主动印象管理动机中介了自恋钦佩与大学生组织公民行为之间的关系,防御性印象管理动机中介了自恋竞争与大学生组织公民行为之间的关系;(3)团队合作、人际关系和乐观主义正向调节了自恋钦佩与主动印象管理动机之间的关系,并且这些变量正向调节了主动自恋通过主动印象管理动机对大学生组织公民行为的间接影响。
我们发现,具有自恋钦佩的大学生比具有自恋竞争的大学生表现出更多的组织公民行为。此外,自恋钦佩通过主动印象管理动机对组织公民行为产生积极影响,而自恋竞争通过防御性印象管理动机对组织公民行为产生消极影响。最后,团队合作、人际关系和乐观主义显著正向中介了自恋钦佩与主动印象管理动机之间的关系,以及自恋钦佩通过主动印象管理动机对组织公民行为的间接影响。然而,团队合作、人际关系和乐观主义对自恋竞争与防御性印象管理动机之间关系的直接影响,以及自恋竞争通过防御性印象管理动机对组织公民行为的间接影响并不显著。