Fufa Daba Bulto, Diriba Tadele Akeba, Dame Kenenisa Tadesse, Debusho Legesse Kassa
Department of Statistics, College of Natural Sciences, Jimma University, Jimma, Ethiopia.
Current address: Department of Statistics, Assosa University, Assosa, Ethiopia.
Arch Public Health. 2023 Jun 25;81(1):117. doi: 10.1186/s13690-023-01130-2.
A major challenge for most tuberculosis programs is the inability of tuberculosis patients to complete treatment for one reason or another. Failure to complete the treatment contributes to the emergence of multidrug-resistant TB. This study aimed to evaluate the risk factors for time to loss to follow-up treatment by considering death as a competing risk event among tuberculosis patients admitted to directly observed treatment short course at Ambo General Hospital, Ambo, Ethiopia.
Data collected from 457 tuberculosis patients from January 2018 to January 2022 were used for the analysis. The cause-specific hazard and sub-distribution hazard models for competing risks were used to model the outcome of interest and to identify the prognostic factors associated to treatment loss to follow-up. Loss to follow-up was used as an outcome measure and death as a competing event.
Of the 457 tuberculosis patients enrolled, 54 (11.8%) were loss to follow-up their treatment and 33 (7.2%) died during the follow up period. The median time of loss to follow-up starting from the date of treatment initiation was 4.2 months. The cause-specific hazard and sub-distribution hazard models revealed that sex, place of residence, HIV status, contact history, age and baseline weights of patients were significant risk factors associated with time to loss to follow-up treatment. The findings showed that the estimates of the covariates effects were different for the cause specific and sub-distribution hazard models. The maximum relative difference observed for the covariate between the cause specific and sub-distribution hazard ratios was 12.2%.
Patients who were male, rural residents, HIV positive, and aged 41 years or older were at higher risk of loss to follow-up their treatment. This underlines the need that tuberculosis patients, especially those in risk categories, be made aware of the length of the directly observed treatment short course and the effects of discontinuing treatment.
对于大多数结核病防治项目而言,一个主要挑战是结核病患者因各种原因无法完成治疗。治疗未完成会导致耐多药结核病的出现。本研究旨在通过将死亡视为埃塞俄比亚安博市安博综合医院接受直接观察短程治疗的结核病患者中的一个竞争风险事件,评估失访治疗时间的风险因素。
分析2018年1月至2022年1月期间从457例结核病患者收集的数据。使用竞争风险的特定病因风险模型和亚分布风险模型来模拟感兴趣的结果,并确定与失访治疗相关的预后因素。将失访用作结局指标,将死亡用作竞争事件。
在纳入的457例结核病患者中,54例(11.8%)失访治疗,33例(7.2%)在随访期间死亡。从治疗开始日期起失访的中位时间为4.2个月。特定病因风险模型和亚分布风险模型显示,患者的性别、居住地点、艾滋病毒感染状况、接触史、年龄和基线体重是与失访治疗时间相关的显著风险因素。结果表明,特定病因风险模型和亚分布风险模型的协变量效应估计值不同。特定病因风险模型和亚分布风险比率之间观察到的协变量最大相对差异为12.2%。
男性、农村居民、艾滋病毒阳性以及年龄在41岁及以上的患者失访治疗的风险较高。这突出表明需要让结核病患者,尤其是处于风险类别的患者,了解直接观察短程治疗的时长以及中断治疗的影响。