Hilton Christopher, Kapaj Armand, Fabrikant Sara I
Geographic Information Visualization & Analysis (GIVA), Department of Geography and Digital Society Initiative, University of Zurich, Switzerland.
J Cogn. 2023 Jul 12;6(1):41. doi: 10.5334/joc.307. eCollection 2023.
Primacy and recency features of serial memory are a hallmark of typical memory functions that have been observed for a wide array of tasks. Recently, the ubiquity of this serial position effect has been supported for objects learned during navigation, with canonical serial position functions observed for sequence memory of landmarks that were encountered along a route during a highly controlled virtual navigation task. In the present study, we extended those findings to a real-world navigation task in which participants actively walked a route through a city whilst using a navigation aid featuring either realistic or abstract landmark visualisation styles. Analyses of serial position functions (i.e., absolute sequence knowledge) and sequence lags (i.e., relative sequence knowledge) yielded similar profiles to those observed in a lab based virtual navigation task from previous work and non-spatial list learning studies. There were strong primacy effects for serial position memory in both conditions; recency effects only in the realistic visualisation condition; a non-uniform distribution of item-lags peaking at lag +1; and an overall bias towards positive lags for both visualisation conditions. The findings demonstrate that benchmark serial position memory effects can be observed in uncontrolled, real-world behaviour. In a navigation context, the results support the notion that general memory mechanisms are involved in spatial learning, and that landmark sequence knowledge is a feature of spatial knowledge which is affected by navigation aids.
系列记忆的首因效应和近因效应是典型记忆功能的一个标志,在大量任务中都有观察到。最近,这种系列位置效应的普遍性在导航过程中学习的物体上得到了支持,在一项高度受控的虚拟导航任务中,沿着路线遇到的地标序列记忆呈现出典型的系列位置功能。在本研究中,我们将这些发现扩展到一项现实世界的导航任务中,参与者在使用具有逼真或抽象地标可视化样式的导航辅助工具时,积极地在城市中行走一条路线。对系列位置功能(即绝对序列知识)和序列滞后(即相对序列知识)的分析产生了与先前工作中基于实验室的虚拟导航任务以及非空间列表学习研究中观察到的类似特征。在两种情况下,系列位置记忆都有很强的首因效应;近因效应仅在逼真可视化条件下出现;项目滞后的分布不均匀,在滞后 +1 处达到峰值;并且两种可视化条件下都总体偏向正滞后。这些发现表明,在不受控制的现实世界行为中可以观察到基准系列位置记忆效应。在导航背景下,结果支持这样一种观点,即一般记忆机制参与空间学习,并且地标序列知识是空间知识的一个特征,它会受到导航辅助工具的影响。