The unitary postsynaptic response to presynaptic quantal glutamate release is the fundamental basis of excitatory information transfer between neurons. The view, however, of individual glutamatergic synaptic connections in a population as homogenous, fixed-strength units of neural communication is becoming increasingly scrutinized. Here, we used minimal stimulation of individual glutamatergic afferent axons to evoke single synapse resolution postsynaptic responses from central sensory lamina I neurons in an adult rat spinal slice preparation. We detected unitary events exhibiting a NMDA receptor component with distinct kinetic properties across synapses conferred by specific GluN2 subunit composition, indicative of GluN2 subtype-based postsynaptic heterogeneity. GluN2A, 2A and 2B, or 2B and 2D synaptic predominance functioned on distinct lamina I neuron types to narrowly, intermediately, or widely tune, respectively, the duration of evoked unitary depolarization events from resting membrane potential, which enabled individual synapses to grade differentially depolarizing steps during temporally patterned afferent input. Our results lead to a model wherein a core locus of proteomic complexity prevails at this central glutamatergic sensory synapse that involves distinct GluN2 subtype configurations. These findings have major implications for subthreshold integrative capacity and transmission strength in spinal lamina I and other CNS regions.