Fine Peter, Leung Albert, Tonni Ingrid, Louca Chris
UCL Eastman Dental Institute, London WC1E 6ED, UK.
Department of Medical and Surgical Specialties, Radiological Sciences and Public Health, Dental School, University of Brescia, 25121 Brescia, Italy.
Dent J (Basel). 2023 Jun 30;11(7):164. doi: 10.3390/dj11070164.
Feedback is essential to improve student learning and motivation and to encourage curriculum development by teachers. This study looked at feedback to and from dental students from a qualitative perspective.
Dental teachers were recruited exclusively to this study from the membership of the Association for Dental Education in Europe (ADEE). Delegates from each of the four annual ADEE conferences were invited to attend focus groups to discuss aspects of feedback. Focus groups established an individual theme for the respective conferences: (i) the role of the teacher in delivering feedback; (ii) feedback from the students' perspective; (iii) changes to feedback due to the COVID-19 pandemic; and (iv) integrating feedback with assessments.
Qualitative data collected from the conference delegates were diverse and thought provoking. Delegates reported different styles of feedback varying from individual, personal feedback to no feedback at all. An enforced and mostly positive adaptation to online delivery during the COVID-19 pandemic was reported. A partial return to pre-pandemic practices was described.
Feedback is well recognized by students and teachers as contributing to learning. A universal approach to delivering feedback as part of the student learning process can be challenging due to a multitude of variables. Many aspects of changes in dental education, teaching, and feedback practices adopted as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic have been retained post-pandemic, thereby accelerating the anticipated progression to online teaching.
反馈对于提高学生的学习效果和学习动力以及促进教师进行课程开发至关重要。本研究从定性的角度审视了牙科学生之间的反馈情况。
专门从欧洲牙科教育协会(ADEE)的会员中招募牙科教师参与本研究。邀请了每年四届ADEE会议的代表参加焦点小组,讨论反馈的各个方面。焦点小组为各自的会议确定了一个单独的主题:(i)教师在提供反馈中的作用;(ii)从学生角度看反馈;(iii)由于新冠疫情导致的反馈变化;以及(iv)将反馈与评估相结合。
从会议代表收集到的定性数据多种多样且发人深省。代表们报告了不同的反馈方式,从个性化的个人反馈到完全没有反馈。据报告,在新冠疫情期间对在线教学进行了强制且大多是积极的调整。描述了部分回归到疫情前做法的情况。
学生和教师都充分认识到反馈对学习有帮助。由于存在众多变量,将反馈作为学生学习过程的一部分采用通用方法可能具有挑战性。新冠疫情导致的牙科教育、教学和反馈实践变化的许多方面在疫情后得以保留,从而加速了向在线教学的预期发展。