Department of Human Nutrition, St Francis Xavier University, Antigonish, NS, Canada.
School of Nutrition and Dietetics, Acadia University, Wolfville, NS, Canada.
J Hum Nutr Diet. 2023 Dec;36(6):2127-2146. doi: 10.1111/jhn.13227. Epub 2023 Sep 22.
Dietitians (RDs) are well-positioned to promote sustainable food systems and diets. This research aims to review the literature for how RDs in Canada define sustainability and determine the types of relevant activities that exist in practice as described in published literature.
Using standardised scoping review methods, researchers searched CINAHL, ACASP, PubMed and ENVCOM databases to identify peer-reviewed articles and conducted a grey literature search to locate other publications related to sustainability in Canadian dietetic practice. Qualitative, thematic coding methods were used to examine definitions and existing practice. The PRISMA extension for scoping reviews guided reporting.
The search resulted in 1059 documents and, after screening, 11 peer-reviewed and 16 grey literature documents remained. Ten unique definitions were used, the most common being Sustainable Diets. Definitions were multidimensional, including environmental, social, economic and health dimensions, and 31 unique subtopics. However, existing practice activities appear to reduce actions to one to two dimensions. Existing practice areas well-reflected include Food and Nutrition Expertise, Management and Leadership, Food Provision and Population Health Promotion. Notable gaps include action in Professionalism and Ethics and Nutrition Care.
No single definition supports all professional contexts, and agency in choice of language to define the work is helpful for contextual clarity. Strengthening practitioners' ability to analyse issues using systems thinking and applying this in practice will help to address challenges and reduce risks of trade-offs. Updates to competency standards that reflect the breadth of existing activities, as well as curricular supports or practice standards, are needed.
营养师(RDs)在促进可持续食品系统和饮食方面具有得天独厚的优势。本研究旨在回顾加拿大营养师对可持续性的定义,并确定已发表文献中描述的实践中存在的相关活动类型。
研究人员使用标准化的范围综述方法,在 CINAHL、ACASP、PubMed 和 ENVCOM 数据库中搜索同行评议文章,并进行灰色文献搜索以找到与加拿大饮食实践中的可持续性相关的其他出版物。使用定性、主题编码方法来检查定义和现有实践。PRISMA 扩展用于范围综述指导报告。
搜索结果产生了 1059 篇文献,经过筛选后,留下了 11 篇同行评议文献和 16 篇灰色文献。使用了 10 个独特的定义,最常见的是可持续饮食。这些定义是多维的,包括环境、社会、经济和健康维度,以及 31 个独特的子主题。然而,现有的实践活动似乎将行动减少到一到两个维度。现有实践领域包括食品和营养专业知识、管理和领导力、食品供应和人口健康促进,反映得很好。值得注意的差距包括在专业精神和道德以及营养护理方面的行动。
没有一个单一的定义可以支持所有的专业背景,选择语言来定义工作的自主权有助于明确语境。加强从业者使用系统思维分析问题的能力,并将其应用于实践,将有助于应对挑战并减少权衡的风险。需要更新反映现有活动广泛范围的能力标准,以及课程支持或实践标准。