Kazanina Nina, Poeppel David
University of Bristol, Bristol, UK; Ernst Strüngmann Institute for Neuroscience, Frankfurt, Germany.
Ernst Strüngmann Institute for Neuroscience, Frankfurt, Germany; New York University, New York, NY, USA.
Trends Cogn Sci. 2023 Nov;27(11):996-1007. doi: 10.1016/j.tics.2023.07.012. Epub 2023 Aug 23.
The classical notion of a 'language of thought' (LoT), advanced prominently by the philosopher Jerry Fodor, is an influential position in cognitive science whereby the mental representations underpinning thought are considered to be compositional and productive, enabling the construction of new complex thoughts from more primitive symbolic concepts. LoT theory has been challenged because a neural implementation has been deemed implausible. We disagree. Examples of critical computational ingredients needed for a neural implementation of a LoT have in fact been demonstrated, in particular in the hippocampal spatial navigation system of rodents. Here, we show that cell types found in spatial navigation (border cells, object cells, head-direction cells, etc.) provide key types of representation and computation required for the LoT, underscoring its neurobiological viability.
由哲学家杰里·福多尔大力倡导的“思想语言”(LoT)这一经典概念,是认知科学中的一个有影响力的观点,据此,支撑思维的心理表征被认为具有组合性和生成性,能够从更原始的符号概念构建出新的复杂思想。LoT理论受到了挑战,因为其神经实现方式被认为是不合理的。我们不同意这种观点。事实上,已经证明了LoT神经实现所需的关键计算要素的实例,特别是在啮齿动物的海马体空间导航系统中。在这里,我们表明在空间导航中发现的细胞类型(边界细胞、物体细胞、头部方向细胞等)提供了LoT所需的关键表征和计算类型,强调了其神经生物学可行性。