Population Health Sciences Institute, Faculty of Medical Sciences, Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK.
Patient and Public Involvement Representative and Consumer Panel Member, NIHR Research Design Service (RDS) North East North Cumbria (NENC), Newcastle upon Tyne, UK.
Health Expect. 2024 Feb;27(1):e13860. doi: 10.1111/hex.13860. Epub 2023 Sep 13.
UNderstanding Factors that explain Avoidable hospital admission Inequalities-Research study (UNFAIR) addresses how to reduce health inequalities, particularly for avoidable hospital admissions. Our Patient and Public Involvement and Engagement (PPIE) members broached that health inequalities are complex, challenging to understand and communicate. They identified a need to explore diverse views, including people who have a higher risk of health inequalities. With limited public-facing resources relating to the public's understanding or emotions around health inequalities, this project aimed to fill this gap using co-leadership and co-production.
Members of the public worked with researchers to co-produce and run PPIE workshops. This project was co-led by a member of the public and a researcher. One online workshop open to anyone in England accompanied by three face-to-face workshops were held. Public contributors, including people living in diverse communities, were invited. Inclusive involvement opportunities were offered including flexible ways of involvement and remuneration. To strengthen the key messages' rigour, transcriptions of the audio-recordings from each workshop, with facilitator notes, were analysed using thematic analysis. From the key messages, an animation was co-produced with public contributors with the public's voice being integral throughout.
A total of 58 people took part capturing intersecting and multiple dimensions of marginalisation including people with a range of ages, genders, ethnicities, socioeconomic backgrounds, and members of communities who face exclusion (including people with learning difficulties and experiencing ill-health). The animation highlighted powerful lived experience, for example, some people are dying earlier than expected. Health inequalities conjured up powerful emotions, such as anger and hopelessness. Public views of how to address health inequalities included respecting, accepting and valuing everyone, regardless of, for example, where people live. The animation is publicly available for use by anyone, including decision makers across the health and care system.
Through co-leadership and co-production, this project is an example of inclusive PPIE. This project provided a way for the public's voice to influence policy and practice to inform understanding and action to address health inequalities. The animation provides powerful insights into what health inequalities mean to people with examples of lived experience and corroborates the moral argument for action by decision makers.
Members of the public, including people who were affected or at higher risk of health inequalities, co-led this project and were involved as co-creators and developers from the inception of the project to completion. Their involvement was integral and documented in full throughout the project.
理解导致可避免住院的不平等因素的研究(UNFAIR)旨在探讨如何减少健康不平等,尤其是可避免住院的不平等。我们的患者和公众参与和参与(PPIE)成员提出,健康不平等是复杂的,难以理解和沟通。他们认为需要探索不同的观点,包括那些面临更高健康不平等风险的人。由于与公众对健康不平等的理解或情绪相关的公共资源有限,该项目旨在通过共同领导和共同创作来填补这一空白。
公众成员与研究人员合作共同创作和开展 PPIE 研讨会。该项目由一名公众成员和一名研究人员共同领导。一个对英格兰任何人开放的在线研讨会,以及三个面对面的研讨会。邀请了来自不同社区的公众参与者,包括生活在多样化社区的人。提供了包容性的参与机会,包括灵活的参与方式和报酬。为了增强关键信息的严谨性,使用主题分析对每个研讨会的音频记录的文字记录和主持人笔记进行了分析。从关键信息中,与公众参与者共同创作了一个动画,公众的声音贯穿始终。
共有 58 人参加了会议,捕捉到了边缘化的交叉和多个维度,包括不同年龄、性别、种族、社会经济背景的人,以及面临排斥的社区成员(包括有学习困难和健康状况不佳的人)。该动画突出了强烈的生活体验,例如,有些人比预期的更早去世。健康不平等引发了强烈的情绪,例如愤怒和绝望。公众对如何解决健康不平等的看法包括尊重、接受和重视每个人,无论他们住在哪里。该动画可供包括医疗保健系统内的决策者在内的任何人使用。
通过共同领导和共同创作,该项目是包容性 PPIE 的一个范例。该项目为公众的声音提供了一种方式,以影响政策和实践,从而增进对健康不平等的理解,并采取行动解决健康不平等问题。该动画提供了对健康不平等对人们意味着什么的深刻见解,包括生活体验的例子,并证实了决策者采取行动的道德论据。
公众成员,包括受健康不平等影响或面临更高健康不平等风险的人,共同领导了这个项目,并从项目开始到完成一直作为共同创造者和开发者参与。他们的参与是必不可少的,并在整个项目中得到了充分的记录。