Kochetkova Tatiana, Hanke Markus S, Indermaur Michael, Groetsch Alexander, Remund Stefan, Neuenschwander Beat, Michler Johann, Siebenrock Klaus A, Zysset Philippe, Schwiedrzik Jakob
Empa, Swiss Federal Laboratories for Materials Science and Technology, Thun, Switzerland.
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Inselspital, University of Bern, Switzerland.
Bone. 2023 Dec;177:116920. doi: 10.1016/j.bone.2023.116920. Epub 2023 Sep 26.
Current clinical methods of bone health assessment depend to a great extent on bone mineral density (BMD) measurements. However, these methods only act as a proxy for bone strength and are often only carried out after the fracture occurs. Besides BMD, composition and tissue-level mechanical properties are expected to affect the whole bone's strength and toughness. While the elastic properties of the bone extracellular matrix (ECM) have been extensively investigated over the past two decades, there is still limited knowledge of the yield properties and their relationship to composition and architecture. In the present study, morphological, compositional and micropillar compression bone data was collected from patients who underwent hip arthroplasty. Femoral neck samples from 42 patients were collected together with anonymous clinical information about age, sex and primary diagnosis (coxarthrosis or hip fracture). The femoral neck cortex from the inferomedial region was analyzed in a site-matched manner using a combination of micromechanical testing (nanoindentation, micropillar compression) together with micro-CT and quantitative polarized Raman spectroscopy for both morphological and compositional characterization. Mechanical properties, as well as the sample-level mineral density, were constant over age. Only compositional properties demonstrate weak dependence on patient age: decreasing mineral to matrix ratio (p = 0.02, R = 0.13, 2.6 % per decade) and increasing amide I sub-peak ratio I/I (p = 0.04, R = 0.11, 1.5 % per decade). The patient's sex and diagnosis did not seem to influence investigated bone properties. A clear zonal dependence between interstitial and osteonal cortical zones was observed for compositional and elastic bone properties (p < 0.0001). Site-matched microscale analysis confirmed that all investigated mechanical properties except yield strain demonstrate a positive correlation with the mineral fraction of bone. The output database is the first to integrate the experimentally assessed microscale yield properties, local tissue composition and morphology with the available patient clinical information. The final dataset was used for bone fracture risk prediction in-silico through the principal component analysis and the Naïve Bayes classification algorithm. The analysis showed that the mineral to matrix ratio, indentation hardness and micropillar yield stress are the most relevant parameters for bone fracture risk prediction at 70 % model accuracy (0.71 AUC). Due to the low number of samples, further studies to build a universal fracture prediction algorithm are anticipated with the higher number of patients (N > 200). The proposed classification algorithm together with the output dataset of bone tissue properties can be used for the future comparison of existing methods to evaluate bone quality as well as to form a better understanding of the mechanisms through which bone tissue is affected by aging or disease.
当前骨健康评估的临床方法在很大程度上依赖于骨矿物质密度(BMD)测量。然而,这些方法仅作为骨强度的替代指标,且通常仅在骨折发生后才进行。除了BMD外,成分和组织水平的力学性能预计会影响整个骨骼的强度和韧性。虽然在过去二十年中对骨细胞外基质(ECM)的弹性特性进行了广泛研究,但对于屈服特性及其与成分和结构的关系仍知之甚少。在本研究中,收集了接受髋关节置换术患者的形态学、成分和微柱压缩骨数据。收集了42例患者的股骨颈样本以及关于年龄、性别和初步诊断(髋关节炎或髋部骨折)的匿名临床信息。使用微机械测试(纳米压痕、微柱压缩)与微CT和定量偏振拉曼光谱相结合的方法,以位点匹配的方式对来自下内侧区域的股骨颈皮质进行形态学和成分表征分析。力学性能以及样本水平的矿物质密度随年龄保持恒定。只有成分特性显示出对患者年龄的微弱依赖性:矿物质与基质的比例降低(p = 0.02,R = 0.13,每十年降低2.6%),酰胺I亚峰比值I/I增加(p = 0.04,R = 0.11,每十年增加1.5%)。患者的性别和诊断似乎并未影响所研究的骨特性。在成分和弹性骨特性方面,观察到间质和骨单位皮质区之间存在明显的区域依赖性(p < 0.0001)。位点匹配的微观尺度分析证实,除屈服应变外,所有研究的力学性能均与骨的矿物质分数呈正相关。该输出数据库首次将实验评估的微观尺度屈服特性、局部组织成分和形态与可用的患者临床信息整合在一起。最终数据集通过主成分分析和朴素贝叶斯分类算法用于计算机模拟中的骨折风险预测。分析表明,矿物质与基质的比例、压痕硬度和微柱屈服应力是骨折风险预测的最相关参数,模型准确率为70%(AUC为0.71)。由于样本数量较少,预计将对更多患者(N > 200)进行进一步研究以建立通用的骨折预测算法。所提出的分类算法以及骨组织特性的输出数据集可用于未来比较现有评估骨质量的方法,并更好地理解骨组织受衰老或疾病影响的机制。