Vivaldi Macho Ennio, Gomez Barbieri Gustavo, Lechuga Hernán, Soto-Suazo Mauricio
Department of Psychiatry, Psychiatric Institute "Dr. José Horwitz Barak", Santiago, Chile.
Pregrade Department, Universidad Finis Terrae, Santiago, Chile.
Front Psychiatry. 2023 Sep 18;14:1114738. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2023.1114738. eCollection 2023.
Various mental health hospital models have been tested in Chile since its foundation. The institutional model with the Asylum and the Madhouse prevailed during the nineteenth century and much of the twentieth. But is deinstitutionalizing all psychiatric patients the solution?
A PubMed, Epistemonikos, Lilacs, and Google Scholar Scoping Review was carried out in the last 5 years using the PRISMA-P method and the Scoping review search strategy. The MeSH terms ("Psychiatry/history" AND "Chile") OR ("Mental disorders" AND "therapy") were used during the search. Finally, papers focused on clinical trial therapy evaluation were excluded, and we emphasized the effects of historical evidence.
We identified 35 primary studies, and we counted the number of articles included in the review that potentially met our inclusion criteria and noted how many studies had been missed by our search. We analyzed 10 primary studies and 10 primary historical resources that were included in this study.
The state must become a guarantor and be responsible for its psychiatric patients and provide professional and humanitarian support to its patients, be it through community psychiatry, day hospitals, devices such as mental health clinics, or psychiatric institutes dedicated to teaching and research. Patients should not be left to the free will of their direct relatives, but rather the state should strengthen the primary care system.
自智利建国以来,已对多种心理健康医院模式进行了测试。在19世纪及20世纪的大部分时间里,以收容所和疯人院为代表的机构模式盛行。但将所有精神病患者非机构化就是解决办法吗?
在过去5年中,使用PRISMA - P方法和范围综述搜索策略,对PubMed、Epistemonikos、Lilacs和谷歌学术进行了范围综述。搜索过程中使用了医学主题词(“精神病学/历史”和“智利”)或(“精神障碍”和“治疗”)。最后,排除了专注于临床试验治疗评估的论文,并强调历史证据的影响。
我们确定了35项初步研究,并统计了综述中可能符合纳入标准的文章数量,并记录了搜索遗漏的研究数量。我们分析了本研究中包含的10项初步研究和10项主要历史资料。
国家必须成为担保人,对其精神病患者负责,并为患者提供专业和人道主义支持,无论是通过社区精神病学、日间医院、心理健康诊所等机构,还是致力于教学和研究的精神病研究所。患者不应任由其直系亲属随意处置,相反,国家应加强初级保健系统。