Cardona-Arias Jaiberth Antonio, Higuita-Gutiérrez Luis Felipe, Carmona-Fonseca Jaime
School of Microbiology, University of Antioquia, Medellín, Colombia.
School of Medicine, Universidad Cooperativa de Colombia, Medellín, Colombia.
Malar J. 2023 Oct 6;22(1):299. doi: 10.1186/s12936-023-04734-9.
The meanings and experiences related to malaria in pregnancy (MiP) and its processes of social determination of health (PSDH) have not been reported in the world scientific literature. The objective was to understand the meanings and experiences of MiP, and to explain their PSDH in an endemic area from Colombia, 2022.
Critical ethnography with 46 pregnant women and 31 healthcare workers. In-depth and semi-structured interviews, focus group discussions, participant and non-participant observations, and field diaries were applied. A phenomenological-hermeneutic analysis, saturation and triangulation was carried out. The methodological rigor criteria were reflexivity, credibility, auditability, and transferability.
At the singular level, participants indicated different problems in antenatal care and malaria control programmes, pregnant women were lacking knowledge about MiP, and malaria care was restricted to cases with high obstetric risk. Three additional levels that explain the PSDH of MiP were identified: (i) limitations of malaria control policies, and health-system, geographic, cultural and economic barriers by MiP diagnosis and treatment; (ii) problems of public health programmes and antenatal care; (iii) structural problems such as monetary poverty, scarcity of resources for public health and inefficiency in their use, lacking community commitment to preventive actions, and breach of institutional responsibilities of health promoter entity, municipalities and health services provider institutions.
Initiatives for MiP control are concentrated at the singular level, PDSH identified in this research show the need to broaden the field of action, increase health resources, and improve public health programmes and antenatal care. It is also necessary to impact the reciprocal relationships of MiP with economic and cultural dimensions, although these aspects are increasingly diminished with the predominance and naturalization of neoliberal logic in health.
妊娠疟疾(MiP)相关的意义和经历及其健康社会决定因素(PSDH)过程在世界科学文献中尚未见报道。目的是了解MiP的意义和经历,并解释2022年哥伦比亚一个流行地区的PSDH。
对46名孕妇和31名医护人员进行批判性人种志研究。采用深入和半结构化访谈、焦点小组讨论、参与和非参与观察以及实地日记。进行了现象学诠释分析、饱和度分析和三角验证。方法严谨性标准包括反思性、可信度、可审计性和可转移性。
在个体层面,参与者指出了产前护理和疟疾控制项目中的不同问题,孕妇缺乏关于MiP的知识,疟疾护理仅限于产科风险高的病例。确定了另外三个解释MiP的PSDH的层面:(i)疟疾控制政策的局限性以及MiP诊断和治疗的卫生系统、地理、文化和经济障碍;(ii)公共卫生项目和产前护理的问题;(iii)结构性问题,如货币贫困、公共卫生资源稀缺及其使用效率低下、社区对预防行动缺乏承诺以及健康促进实体、市政当局和卫生服务提供机构的机构责任缺失。
MiP控制举措集中在个体层面,本研究中确定的PDSH表明需要扩大行动领域、增加卫生资源,并改善公共卫生项目和产前护理。还需要影响MiP与经济和文化层面的相互关系,尽管随着新自由主义逻辑在卫生领域的主导和常态化,这些方面的影响日益减弱。