Cole Alissa M, Chan Elizabeth S M, Gaye Fatou, Spiegel Jamie A, Soto Elia F, Kofler Michael J
Florida State University.
University of South Alabama.
J Educ Psychol. 2023 Jul;115(5):700-714. doi: 10.1037/edu0000806. Epub 2023 Jun 1.
The 'simple view of reading' is an influential model of reading comprehension which asserts that children's reading comprehension performance can be explained entirely by their decoding and language comprehension skills. Children with ADHD often exhibit difficulty across all three of these reading domains on standardized achievement tests, yet it is unclear whether the simple view of reading is sufficient to explain reading comprehension performance for these children. The current study was the first to use multiple indicators and latent estimates to examine the veracity of key predictions from the simple view of reading in a clinically-evaluated sample of 250 children with and without ADHD (ages 8-13, M=10.29, SD=1.47; 93 girls; 70% White/Non-Hispanic). Results of the full-sample structural equation model revealed that decoding and language comprehension explained all (R=.99) of the variance in reading comprehension for children with and without ADHD. Further, multigroup modeling (ADHD, Non-ADHD) indicated that there was no difference in the quantity of variance explained for children with ADHD versus clinically-evaluated children without ADHD, and that the quantity of explained variance did not differ from 100% for either group. Sensitivity analyses indicated that these effects were generally robust to control for monomethod bias, time sampling error, and IQ. These findings are consistent with 'simple view' predictions that decoding and language comprehension are both and together for explaining children's reading comprehension skills. The findings extend prior work by indicating that the 'simple view' holds for both children with ADHD and clinically-evaluated children without ADHD.
“阅读的简单观点”是一种有影响力的阅读理解模型,该模型认为儿童的阅读理解表现可以完全由他们的解码和语言理解能力来解释。患有注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)的儿童在标准化成就测试的所有这三个阅读领域中往往都表现出困难,然而尚不清楚阅读的简单观点是否足以解释这些儿童的阅读理解表现。当前的研究首次使用多个指标和潜在估计来检验在一个对250名有或没有ADHD的儿童(年龄8 - 13岁,M = 10.29,SD = 1.47;93名女孩;70%为白人/非西班牙裔)进行临床评估的样本中,来自阅读简单观点的关键预测的准确性。全样本结构方程模型的结果表明,解码和语言理解解释了有和没有ADHD的儿童在阅读理解方面的所有(R =.99)方差。此外,多组建模(ADHD组、非ADHD组)表明,对于患有ADHD的儿童与经过临床评估的没有ADHD的儿童,所解释的方差量没有差异,并且两组中所解释的方差量与100%均无差异。敏感性分析表明,这些效应在控制单方法偏差、时间抽样误差和智商方面通常是稳健的。这些发现与“简单观点”的预测一致,即解码和语言理解对于解释儿童的阅读理解技能都是且共同是 。这些发现扩展了先前的研究工作,表明“简单观点”对患有ADHD的儿童和经过临床评估的没有ADHD的儿童都成立。 (注:原文中“both and together for”部分表述不完整,翻译时保留了原文的不完整性)