Yokomitsu Kengo, Takashina Hikari N, Takebayashi Yoshitake, Muranaka Seiji
School of Psychological Sciences, University of Human Environments, Ehime, Japan.
Research Center for Child Mental Development, Chiba University, Chiba, Japan.
JMIR Res Protoc. 2023 Nov 3;12:e44469. doi: 10.2196/44469.
With an increase in both the number of mental health disorders people are experiencing and the difficulty in accessing mental health care, the demand for accessible mental health care services has increased. The use of mobile devices has allowed people to receive care in their daily lives without restrictions on time or location. However, the majority of publicly available mobile health apps are not evidence-based, and the top-rated apps are not always safe or user-friendly and may not offer clinically beneficial results.
This study aims to create a cultural adaptation of the American Psychiatric Association's comprehensive app evaluation framework in Japan using a web-based modified Delphi expert consensus.
A web-based modified Delphi study includes developing the Japanese version of the comprehensive app evaluation framework and 3 Delphi rounds. In the first round, our working group sends a questionnaire to the panelists, who then complete it. In the second and third rounds, the working group sends a questionnaire and a summary of the panelists' answers based on each of the previous rounds. The panelists answer the questionnaires based on this summary. The summarization procedure is automated to help reduce the biases that can be generated when panelists' answers are summarized and when the panelists receive them. The working group sends only the result of the summarization with the next round's questionnaire. All interactions between the working group and the panelists will be conducted on Qualtrics (Qualtrics Japan LLC), a questionnaire platform. To culturally validate the comprehensive mental health app evaluation framework, participants from the following three categories will be recruited in Japan: (1) researchers, (2) practitioners, and (3) app developers.
This study received funding from a crowdfunding campaign in Japan (April 2023). The Delphi study began in January 2023 and will be completed in December 2023. We had already completed the translation of the 105 original app evaluation item questions by December 2022.
While the need for treatment using mental health apps is increasing, no framework that can be used to develop a centralized database for health apps is available or accessible, and no consensus has been reached among stakeholders in Japan about an appropriate framework. The results of the web-based modified Delphi method presented in this paper may provide direction for the development and use of mental health apps in the future among the relevant stakeholders. Furthermore, this study will enhance recognition of the framework among researchers, clinicians, mental health app developers, and users, in addition to devising new instruments to help users or practitioners efficiently choose the right app for their situations.
INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT IDENTIFIER (IRRID): PRR1-10.2196/44469.
随着人们经历的心理健康障碍数量增加以及获得心理健康护理的难度加大,对可及的心理健康护理服务的需求也在上升。移动设备的使用使人们能够在日常生活中不受时间或地点限制地接受护理。然而,大多数公开可用的移动健康应用程序并非基于证据,而且评分最高的应用程序并不总是安全或用户友好的,可能也无法提供临床上有益的结果。
本研究旨在通过基于网络的改良德尔菲专家共识,对美国精神病学协会的综合应用程序评估框架进行日本文化适应性调整。
基于网络的改良德尔菲研究包括开发综合应用程序评估框架的日语版本以及三轮德尔菲调查。在第一轮中,我们的工作组向专家小组成员发送问卷,然后由他们完成问卷。在第二轮和第三轮中,工作组发送问卷以及基于前一轮的专家小组成员答案总结。专家小组成员根据此总结回答问卷。总结程序是自动化的,以帮助减少在总结专家小组成员答案以及专家小组成员接收答案时可能产生的偏差。工作组在下一轮问卷中仅发送总结结果。工作组与专家小组成员之间的所有互动将在问卷平台Qualtrics(Qualtrics Japan LLC)上进行。为了对综合心理健康应用程序评估框架进行文化验证,将在日本招募以下三类参与者:(1)研究人员,(2)从业者,(3)应用程序开发者。
本研究获得了日本一项众筹活动(2023年4月)的资金。德尔菲研究于2023年1月开始,将于2023年12月完成。到2022年12月,我们已经完成了105个原始应用程序评估项目问题的翻译。
虽然使用心理健康应用程序进行治疗的需求在增加,但目前没有可用于开发健康应用程序集中数据库的框架,日本的利益相关者也未就合适的框架达成共识。本文介绍的基于网络的改良德尔菲方法的结果可能为未来相关利益者开发和使用心理健康应用程序提供指导。此外,本研究除了设计新工具以帮助用户或从业者根据自身情况有效选择合适的应用程序外,还将提高研究人员、临床医生、心理健康应用程序开发者和用户对该框架的认识。
国际注册报告识别号(IRRID):PRR1-10.2196/44469。