Purrer Veronika, Pohl Emily, Lueckel Julia M, Borger Valeri, Sauer Malte, Radbruch Alexander, Wüllner Ullrich, Schmeel Frederic Carsten
Department of Neurology, University Hospital Bonn, 53127 Bonn, Germany.
German Center of Neurodegenerative Diseases (DZNE), 53127 Bonn, Germany.
Brain Commun. 2023 Oct 13;5(6):fcad271. doi: 10.1093/braincomms/fcad271. eCollection 2023.
Essential tremor and Parkinson's disease patients may present with various tremor types. Overlapping tremor features can be challenging to diagnosis and misdiagnosis is common. Although underlying neurodegenerative mechanisms are suggested, neuroimaging studies arrived at controversial results and often the different tremor types were not considered. We investigated whether different tremor types displayed distinct structural brain features. Structural MRI of 61 patients with essential tremor and 29 with tremor-dominant Parkinson's disease was analysed using a fully automated artificial-intelligence-based brain volumetry to compare volumes of several cortical and subcortical regions. Furthermore, essential tremor subgroups with and without rest tremor or more pronounced postural and kinetic tremor were investigated. Deviations from an internal reference collective of age- and sex-adjusted healthy controls and volumetric differences between groups were examined; regression analysis was used to determine the contribution of disease-related factors on volumetric measurements. Compared with healthy controls, essential tremor and tremor-dominant Parkinson's disease patients displayed deviations in the occipital lobes, hippocampus, putamen, pallidum and mesencephalon while essential tremor patients exhibited decreased volumes within the nucleus caudatus and thalamus. Analysis of covariance revealed similar volumetric patterns in both diseases. Essential tremor patients without rest tremor showed a significant atrophy within the thalamus compared to tremor-dominant Parkinson's disease and atrophy of the mesencephalon and putamen were found in both subgroups compared to essential tremor with rest tremor. Disease-related factors contribute to volumes of occipital lobes in both diseases and to volumes of temporal lobes in essential tremor and the putamen in Parkinson's disease. Fully automated artificial-intelligence-based volumetry provides a fast and rater-independent method to investigate brain volumes in different neurological disorders and allows comparisons with an internal reference collective. Our results indicate that essential tremor and tremor-dominant Parkinson's disease share structural changes, indicative of neurodegenerative mechanisms, particularly of the basal-ganglia-thalamocortical circuitry. A discriminating, possibly disease-specific involvement of the thalamus was found in essential tremor patients without rest tremor and the mesencephalon and putamen in tremor-dominant Parkinson's disease and essential tremor without rest tremor.
特发性震颤和帕金森病患者可能表现出多种震颤类型。震颤特征重叠可能给诊断带来挑战,误诊很常见。尽管有潜在的神经退行性机制的提示,但神经影像学研究得出了有争议的结果,而且不同的震颤类型往往未被考虑。我们研究了不同的震颤类型是否表现出不同的脑结构特征。使用基于人工智能的全自动脑容量测量法分析了61例特发性震颤患者和29例震颤为主型帕金森病患者的结构磁共振成像,以比较几个皮质和皮质下区域的体积。此外,还对有无静止性震颤或姿势性和动作性震颤更明显的特发性震颤亚组进行了研究。检查了与年龄和性别匹配的健康对照内部参考群体的偏差以及组间的体积差异;使用回归分析来确定疾病相关因素对体积测量的影响。与健康对照相比,特发性震颤和震颤为主型帕金森病患者在枕叶、海马体、壳核、苍白球和中脑存在偏差,而特发性震颤患者尾状核和丘脑体积减小。协方差分析显示两种疾病的体积模式相似。与震颤为主型帕金森病相比,无静止性震颤的特发性震颤患者丘脑有明显萎缩,与有静止性震颤的特发性震颤相比,两个亚组均发现中脑和壳核萎缩。疾病相关因素对两种疾病的枕叶体积、特发性震颤的颞叶体积以及帕金森病的壳核体积均有影响。基于人工智能的全自动体积测量法提供了一种快速且与评估者无关的方法来研究不同神经系统疾病中的脑体积,并允许与内部参考群体进行比较。我们的结果表明,特发性震颤和震颤为主型帕金森病存在共同的结构变化,提示神经退行性机制,特别是基底神经节 - 丘脑皮质环路。在无静止性震颤的特发性震颤患者以及震颤为主型帕金森病和无静止性震颤的特发性震颤患者中,发现丘脑存在有鉴别意义的、可能具有疾病特异性的受累情况,以及中脑和壳核的受累情况。