Li Y W, Liu Y, Li X, Wang S N, Zheng G Y
Department of Ophthalmology, the First Affiliated Hospital of Zhengzhou University, Zhengzhou 450052, China.
Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi. 2023 Dec 11;59(12):1019-1029. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn112142-20230220-00060.
To investigate the effects of the application of a low addition refractive multifocal intraocular lens (IOL) using the micromonovision design in the non-dominant eye with different degrees of preset myopia on the visual acuity, visual function and visual quality after bilateral cataract surgery. In this randomized controlled trial, patients who were proposed to undergo bilateral phacoemulsification combined with rotational asymmetric refractive IOL (MF15 IOL) implantation at the First Affiliated Hospital of Zhengzhou University between September 2020 and August 2022 were included. All patients were divided into three groups using the random number method. The target refraction of the IOL in the dominant eye was 0.00 D. Non-dominant eyes were given different preoperative IOL reserve refractions, with the reserved near additional degree>0.20 D and≤0.40 D as the low addition,>0.40 D and≤0.60 D as the medium addition, and>0.60 D and≤0.80 D as the high addition. We compared uncorrected distance visual acuity (UDVA), uncorrected intermediate visual acuity (UIVA) and uncorrected near visual acuity (UNVA) of monocular and binocular eyes at 1 day, 1 month and 3 months postoperatively in the 3 groups of patients. Furthermore, the contrast sensitivity, stereopsis, defocus curves and visual quality questionnaire results of binocular eyes were compared at 3 months postoperatively. The statistical methods mainly used were chi-square test, two-factor repeated measures ANOVA, one-way ANOVA, LSD test, Kruskal-Wallis test, and paired -test. A total of 110 patients (220 eyes) were enrolled in the study, including 48 males and 62 females, with an average age of (59.74±9.38) years. There were 40 patients (80 eyes) in the low additional degree group, 37 patients (74 eyes) in the medium additional degree group, and 33 patients (66 eyes) in the high additional degree group. The differences in distance, intermediate and near visual acuity of the dominant eyes among the three groups were not statistically significant at different measurement timepoints postoperatively (>0.05). The differences in intermediate and near visual acuity of the non-dominant eyes were also not statistically significant (>0.05) among the three groups. In contrast, at 3 months, the UDVA of the non-dominant eyes in the low additional degree group (0.04±0.06) and medium additional degree group (0.04±0.07) was significantly higher than that in the high additional degree group (0.08±0.09) (=4.776, =0.011, bias =0.086). There was no statistically significant difference in binocular uncorrected distance, intermediate and near visual acuity among the three groups at different postoperative timepoints (>0.05). The binocular UDVA, UIVA and UNVA (logMAR visual acuity) at 3 months postoperatively were -0.04±0.04, 0.03±0.08, 0.10±0.13 in the low addition group, -0.01±0.05, -0.02±0.06, 0.09±0.10 in the medium addition group, and 0.02±0.07, 0.01±0.09, 0.16±0.11 in the high addition group. At 3 months postoperatively, the binocular contrast sensitivity of the low additional degree group was significantly higher than that of the high additional degree group (<0.05), except that there was no significant difference at the spatial frequency of 6 cycles per degree in the absence of glare (>0.05). The binocular contrast sensitivity of the medium additional degree group was significantly higher than that of the high additional degree group at the spatial frequencies of 6 and 18 cycles per degree in the glare condition (<0.05). The difference in the binocular contrast sensitivity between the low and medium additional degree groups did not reach statistical significance (>0.05). The peak of the binocular defocus curve in the three groups was significantly wider than that in the monocular eyes, and the decline trend was more gentle, with no trough in the middle, and the visual acuity could be maintained above 0.2 (logMAR visual acuity) in the 0.00 D to -3.00 D defocus range. There was no significant difference in the postoperative near stereopsis results among the three groups (>0.05), with the percentage of near stereopsis sharpness≤60″ reaching 90.00% (36/40), 89.19% (33/37) and 78.79% (26/33), respectively. The proportions of VF-14 scores≥90 in the postoperative questionnaire were 90% (36/40), 91.89% (34/37) and 81.82% (27/33) for the low, medium and high additional degree groups, respectively. The differences in the probability of photic phenomena and spectacles-independent rate were not statistically significant (>0.05). The use of micromonovision design for bilateral implantation of a rotational asymmetric refractive MF15 IOL, with the non-dominant eye reserved for different near additional degrees, can enable cataract patients to have significantly improved binocular full-range vision, visual function and visual quality. When the degree of reserved near additions in the non-dominant eye preoperatively is>0.20 D and≤0.60 D, it can ensure sufficient binocular UDVA, UIVA and UNVA after surgery, and meanwhile help to obtain superior contrast sensitivity and stereopsis, as well as a satisfactory spectacles-independent rate and low incidence of photic phenomena.
探讨在非主导眼应用采用微单眼视设计的低附加度数折射型多焦点人工晶状体(IOL),预设不同近视度数对双眼白内障手术后视力、视觉功能和视觉质量的影响。在这项随机对照试验中,纳入了2020年9月至2022年8月期间在郑州大学第一附属医院拟行双眼超声乳化联合旋转不对称折射型IOL(MF15 IOL)植入术的患者。所有患者采用随机数字法分为三组。主导眼IOL的目标屈光度为0.00 D。非主导眼给予不同的术前IOL储备屈光度,储备近附加度数>0.20 D且≤0.40 D为低附加,>0.40 D且≤0.60 D为中附加,>0.60 D且≤0.80 D为高附加。比较三组患者术后1天、1个月和3个月时单眼和双眼的未矫正远视力(UDVA)、未矫正中视力(UIVA)和未矫正近视力(UNVA)。此外,比较术后3个月时双眼的对比敏感度、立体视、散焦曲线和视觉质量问卷结果。主要采用的统计方法有卡方检验、两因素重复测量方差分析、单因素方差分析、LSD检验、Kruskal-Wallis检验和配对检验。本研究共纳入110例患者(220只眼),其中男性48例,女性62例,平均年龄(59.74±9.38)岁。低附加度数组40例(80只眼),中附加度数组37例(74只眼),高附加度数组33例(66只眼)。三组患者术后不同测量时间点主导眼的远、中、近视力差异均无统计学意义(>0.05)。三组非主导眼中、近视力差异也无统计学意义(>0.05)。相比之下,术后3个月时,低附加度数组(0.04±0.06)和中附加度数组(0.04±0.07)非主导眼的UDVA显著高于高附加度数组(0.08±0.09)(χ² =4.776,P =0.011,偏倚 =0.086)。三组患者术后不同时间点双眼未矫正远、中、近视力差异均无统计学意义(>0.05)。术后3个月时,低附加度数组双眼的UDVA、UIVA和UNVA(logMAR视力)分别为-0.04±0.04、0.03±0.08、0.10±0.13,中附加度数组分别为-0.01±0.05、-0.02±0.06、0.09±0.10,高附加度数组分别为0.02±0.07、0.01±0.09、0.16±0.11。术后3个月时,低附加度数组双眼的对比敏感度显著高于高附加度数组(P<0.05),在无眩光情况下每度6周空间频率时除外(>0.05)。在眩光条件下,中附加度数组双眼在每度6周和18周空间频率时的对比敏感度显著高于高附加度数组(P<0.05)。低、中附加度数组双眼对比敏感度差异未达到统计学意义(>0.05)。三组双眼散焦曲线的峰值显著宽于单眼,下降趋势更平缓,中间无低谷,在0.00 D至-3.00 D散焦范围内视力可维持在0.2(logMAR视力)以上。三组术后近立体视结果差异无统计学意义(>0.05),近立体视锐度≤60″的比例分别达到90.00%(36/40)、89.19%(33/37)和78.79%(26/33)。术后问卷中VF-14评分≥90的比例,低、中、高附加度数组分别为90%(36/40)、91.89%(34/37)和81.82%(27/33)。光现象概率和无眼镜率差异无统计学意义(>0.05)。采用微单眼视设计双侧植入旋转不对称折射型MF15 IOL,非主导眼预留不同近附加度数,可使白内障患者双眼全范围视力、视觉功能和视觉质量显著改善。术前非主导眼预留近附加度数>0.20 D且≤0.60 D时,可确保术后双眼有足够的UDVA、UIVA和UNVA,同时有助于获得较好的对比敏感度和立体视,以及令人满意的无眼镜率和低光现象发生率。