Çetin Baki Volkan, Bakırcıoğlu Sancar, Çiftci Sadettin, Söylemez Mehmet Salih, Erkuş Serkan, Turhan Yalçın, Çamurcu İsmail Yalkın, Duman Serda, Yıldırım Timur, Memişoğlu Kaya, Şenaran Hakan, Ömeroğlu Hakan
Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, Harran University, Faculty of Medicine, Şanlıurfa, Turkey.
Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, TOBB Economy and Technology University, Ankara, Turkey.
Acta Orthop Traumatol Turc. 2023 Dec 22;57(6):322-8. doi: 10.5152/j.aott.2023.23080.
This study aimed to evaluate the diagnosis and treatment preferences of orthopedic surgeons in developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) cases under the age of 1 in Türkiye with a higher incidence of DDH, estimated to be around 5-15 per 1000 live births.
This was a nationwide cross-sectional survey. A link for the online survey, including 16 multiple-choice questions, was sent to the email group of the National Orthopedic Society.
Among 233 filled-out surveys, 211 met the inclusion criteria. Half of the participants had experience of <10 years as orthopedic surgeons, managed <25% of pediatric patients in daily practice, and treated <25 DDH cases per year before walking age. Ninety-seven percent used more than one method, hip ultrasound the most common, for exact diagnosis of DDH under 6 months. Pavlik harness was the most commonly preferred brace, but the use of Tübingen orthosis increased among experienced surgeons. The uppermost age limit for bracing was higher in surgeons dealing with more pediatric patients and treating more DDH cases. Dislocated hips and hips requiring closed/open reduction were more commonly referred to other surgeons by less experienced surgeons in terms of years, number of pediatric patients, and treated DDH cases per year. The lowest age limit for intervention under general anesthesia was lower in surgeons treating >25 DDH cases per year. Over one-third used both anterior and medial approach open reduction, but a trend to anterior open reduction alone was more evident in surgeons treating >50 DDH cases per year. More experienced surgeons were more prone to check the intraoperative reduction with postoperative computed tomography or magnetic resonance imaging. Diagnosis and treatment ages of DDH cases did not significantly change during the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic.
Management preferences of orthopedic surgeons in DDH before walking age primarily depend on the rate of pediatric patients in daily practice and the number of treated DDH cases per year.
本研究旨在评估土耳其1岁以下发育性髋关节发育不良(DDH)病例的诊断和治疗偏好,土耳其的DDH发病率较高,估计每1000例活产中约有5 - 15例。
这是一项全国性的横断面调查。一份包含16个多项选择题的在线调查问卷链接被发送给了国家骨科协会的电子邮件群组。
在233份填写完整的调查问卷中,211份符合纳入标准。一半的参与者作为骨科医生的经验不足10年,日常工作中管理的儿科患者不到25%,且在步行年龄前每年治疗的DDH病例不到25例。97%的人使用不止一种方法,其中髋关节超声是6个月以下DDH精确诊断最常用的方法。帕夫利克吊带是最常用的支具,但经验丰富的外科医生使用图宾根矫形器的比例有所增加。处理更多儿科患者和治疗更多DDH病例的外科医生,其支具治疗的最大年龄上限更高。就工作年限、儿科患者数量和每年治疗的DDH病例数而言,经验较少的外科医生更常将脱位髋关节和需要闭合/开放复位的髋关节转诊给其他外科医生。每年治疗超过25例DDH病例的外科医生,其全身麻醉下干预的最低年龄下限更低。超过三分之一的人同时使用前路和内侧入路开放复位,但每年治疗超过50例DDH病例的外科医生中,单独采用前路开放复位的趋势更为明显。经验更丰富的外科医生更倾向于术后通过计算机断层扫描或磁共振成像检查术中复位情况。在2019冠状病毒病大流行期间,DDH病例的诊断和治疗年龄没有显著变化。
骨科医生对步行年龄前DDH的治疗偏好主要取决于日常工作中儿科患者的比例以及每年治疗的DDH病例数。