Robert Koch Institute, Berlin, Germany.
National Tuberculosis and Lung Diseases Research Institute, Warsaw, Poland.
Euro Surveill. 2024 Jan;29(1). doi: 10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2024.29.1.2300081.
BackgroundEvaluating tuberculosis (TB) notification completeness is important for monitoring TB surveillance systems, while estimating the TB disease burden is crucial for control strategies.AimWe conducted an inventory study to assess TB reporting completeness in Poland in 2018.MethodsUsing a double-pronged inventory approach, we compared notifications of culture-positive TB cases in the National TB Register to records of diagnostic laboratories. We calculated under-reporting both with observed and capture-recapture (CRC)-estimated case numbers. We further compared the notifications by region (i.e. voivodship), sex, and age to aggregated data from hospitalised TB patients, which provided an independent estimate of reporting completeness.ResultsIn 2018, 4,075 culture-positive TB cases were notified in Poland, with 3,789 linked to laboratory records. Laboratories reported further 534 TB patients, of whom 456 were linked to notifications from 2017 or 2019. Thus, 78 (534 - 456) cases were missing in the National TB Register, yielding an observed TB under-reporting of 1.9% (78/(4,075 + 78) × 100). CRC-modelled total number of cases in 2018 was 4,176, corresponding to 2.4% ((4,176 - 4,075)/4,176 × 100) under-reporting. Based on aggregated hospitalisation data from 13 of 16 total voivodeships, under-reporting was 5.1% (3,482/(3,670 - 3,482) × 100), similar in both sexes but varying between voivodeships and age groups.ConclusionsOur results suggest that the surveillance system captures ≥ 90% of estimated TB cases in Poland; thus, the notification rate is a good proxy for the diagnosed TB incidence in Poland. Reporting delays causing discrepancies between data sources could be improved by the planned change from a paper-based to a digital reporting system.
评估结核病(TB)通报的完整性对于监测结核病监测系统非常重要,而估算结核病发病负担对于控制策略至关重要。
我们开展了一项存量研究,以评估 2018 年波兰的结核病报告完整性。
采用双管齐下的存量研究方法,我们将国家结核病登记处中培养阳性结核病病例的通报与诊断实验室的记录进行了比较。我们根据观察到的和捕获再捕获(CRC)估计的病例数计算了漏报率。我们进一步比较了按地区(即 voivodship)、性别和年龄划分的通报情况,与住院结核病患者的汇总数据进行了比较,后者提供了报告完整性的独立估计。
2018 年,波兰共通报了 4075 例培养阳性结核病病例,其中 3789 例与实验室记录相关联。实验室报告了另外 534 例结核病患者,其中 456 例与 2017 年或 2019 年的通报相关联。因此,国家结核病登记处漏报了 78 例(534-456)病例,观察到的结核病漏报率为 1.9%(78/(4075+78)×100)。CRC 模型估计 2018 年的总病例数为 4176 例,漏报率为 2.4%((4176-4075)/4176×100)。根据 16 个 voivodships中的 13 个 voivodships 的住院数据汇总,漏报率为 5.1%(3482/(3670-3482)×100),男女之间相似,但在 voivodships 和年龄组之间存在差异。
我们的结果表明,监测系统在波兰至少捕获了 90%的估计结核病病例;因此,通报率是波兰诊断结核病发病率的良好替代指标。通过计划从基于纸质的报告系统转变为数字报告系统,可以改善导致数据源之间存在差异的报告延迟问题。