Karkalos Nikolaos E, Dekster Lisa, Kudelski Rafał, Karmiris-Obratański Panagiotis
Laboratory of Manufacturing Technology, School of Mechanical Engineering, National Technical University of Athens, 157 80 Athens, Greece.
Department of Manufacturing Systems, Faculty of Mechanical Engineering and Robotics, AGH University of Krakow, 30-059 Krakow, Poland.
Materials (Basel). 2023 Dec 19;17(1):11. doi: 10.3390/ma17010011.
Non-conventional machining processes offer significant advantages over conventional ones, especially in terms of the productivity, cost, and surface integrity of the produced parts due to their higher flexibility. Abrasive waterjet machining, in particular, constitutes an ecologically friendly process with a negligible thermal impact on a workpiece, and it has considerable capabilities for obtaining the desired outcome by regulating some of its numerous parameters. Among these parameters, the abrasive type is particularly important due to its hardness, mesh size, and shape, which lead to considerable deviations on the obtained depth, kerf characteristics, and productivity. Thus, in this work, a comprehensive comparison is conducted on the use of garnet and silicon carbide particles for the slot milling of the Ti-6Al-4V alloy under different conditions. The capabilities of both abrasive materials are evaluated by statistical analysis regarding the depth of penetration, kerf width, kerf taper angle, and material removal rate (MRR), which are obtained under the same process conditions. Finally, a multi-objective optimization based on grey relational analysis (GRA) is performed for several different practical cases. It was found that, although silicon carbide is more efficient in optimizing individual process outputs, the use of a garnet abrasive can lead to considerably better trade-offs between two or more objectives of the machining process.
非传统加工工艺相对于传统加工工艺具有显著优势,特别是在生产效率、成本以及所生产零件的表面完整性方面,这归因于其更高的灵活性。尤其是磨料水射流加工,它是一种生态友好型工艺,对工件的热影响可忽略不计,并且通过调节其众多参数中的一些参数,具有实现预期结果的相当大的能力。在这些参数中,磨料类型因其硬度、粒度和形状而尤为重要,这些因素会导致在获得的深度、切口特性和生产率方面出现相当大的偏差。因此,在这项工作中,对在不同条件下使用石榴石和碳化硅颗粒对Ti-6Al-4V合金进行槽铣加工进行了全面比较。通过对在相同工艺条件下获得的穿透深度、切口宽度、切口锥角和材料去除率(MRR)进行统计分析,评估了两种磨料材料的性能。最后,针对几种不同的实际情况进行了基于灰色关联分析(GRA)的多目标优化。结果发现,尽管碳化硅在优化单个工艺输出方面更有效,但使用石榴石磨料可以在加工过程的两个或多个目标之间实现更好的权衡。